Total number of articles up for deletion review: 31
ArticleAlley
1 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 3 Creator: 34pin6 Nominator: RHaworth
34pin6 1 (1/0) 2009-08-27 86.51.114.4 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-09-04 RHaworth 1 (1/0) 2009-08-27 ![]() |
The result was no consensus. Cirt (talk) 20:11, 11 September 2009 (UTC)
Website where people post articles. No evidence of notability. — RHaworth (Talk | contribs) 09:53, 27 August 2009 (UTC)
The Google Books citations, of which there are several, cite ArticleAlley.Com as a source. Each of these books were published by independent sources. 34pin6 (talk) 21:42, 27 August 2009 (UTC)"The content itself has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the site itself. This criterion includes reliable published works in all forms, such as newspaper and magazine articles, books, television documentaries, websites, and published reports by consumer watchdog organizations."
from user:Uncle G, posted by 34pin6 (talk) 16:07, 3 September 2009 (UTC)"The rationale that underpins the primary notability criterion is that the fact that something has been noted demonstrates that it is notable."
If you go back to my page that you pointed to and read from the top, you'll find non-triviality discussed. What is needed for notability is sources that are actually about the subject, that document it in depth. (In Wikipedia:Notability, you'll find this concept expressed as "significant coverage".) The aforecited book isn't about the subject, for example. It doesn't say one single thing about this subject at all. There's not one single fact on that page, about this subject, that can be taken and added to this article.
If you want to change Dennisthe2's mind — and xe is a reasonable editor whose mind can be changed — show that multiple published works, independent of the subject and from people with good reputations for fact checking and accuracy, document this subject in depth. It's that last part that you aren't addressing. A published work that simply mentions this subject in passing, or that doesn't even give any facts about this subject at all, is not contributing to documenting the subject in depth. Find some sources that do, cite them, and you'll make a case that can potentially change Dennisthe2's mind. Uncle G (talk) 23:38, 3 September 2009 (UTC)
34pin6 (talk) 21:13, 5 September 2009 (UTC)
Axis & Allies Miniatures (land version)
2 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 100 Creator: Jeronimo Nominator: RHaworth
72.177.113.91 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2009-04-05 WhisperToMe 3 (0/3) 2003-11-08 Cantus 3 (1/2) 2004-07-18 Ewlyahoocom 3 (3/0) 2007-08-07 SlackerMom 3 (3/0) 2008-07-17 Kiwipeel 2 (2/0) 2009-03-18 Lir 2 (2/0) 2002-11-09 Hyacinth 2 (1/1) 2005-12-07 Mahanchian 2 (1/1) 2006-02-19 Aesopos 2 (0/2) 2008-07-17 Wolfrock 2 (2/0) 2009-03-18 193.2.69.128 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2004-02-05 Tarek 2 (0/2) 2004-12-05 TomStar81 2 (0/2) 2005-06-26 Whosasking 2 (2/0) 2005-07-10 69.152.196.89 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-03-22 NDCompuGeek 2 (1/1) 2007-04-23 Mrg3105 2 (0/2) 2008-01-01 Van der Hoorn 2 (0/2) 2008-02-24 24.197.172.228 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-03-02 77.79.175.250 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-08-09 CUSENZA Mario 1 (1/0) 2008-08-29 Cocoaguy 1 (0/1) 2008-09-24 Ale jrb 1 (0/1) 2008-11-02 64.251.55.249 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-12-04 Jeronimo 1 (0/1) 2002-02-10 208.33.236.119 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-12-21 David Parker 1 (1/0) 2002-03-09 131.183.81.100 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2002-11-02 Axis WebApps 1 (1/0) 2009-08-29 MartinHarper 1 (0/1) 2003-03-24 Eeekster 1 (1/0) 2009-08-30 Glenn 1 (0/1) 2003-07-12 Jimbreed 1 (0/1) 2003-10-17 Mattworld 1 (0/1) 2003-11-10 E23 1 (0/1) 2003-12-08 Youssefsan 1 (0/1) 2004-05-02 128.210.154.197 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2004-07-29 213.0.215.179 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2004-09-02 Mshonle 1 (0/1) 2004-09-21 63.172.33.194 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2004-11-19 Mixcoatl 1 (1/0) 2004-12-16 Smack 1 (1/0) 2005-01-12 Sverdrup 1 (1/0) 2005-01-13 Margosbot 1 (0/1) 2005-04-27 IgorTrieste 1 (1/0) 2005-06-24 216.86.113.202 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-10-23 70.30.62.129 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-12-06 Jorge Stolfi 1 (1/0) 2006-01-24 UtherSRG 1 (1/0) 2006-04-07 24.180.202.72 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-04-23 204.83.50.114 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-05-01 71.112.0.243 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-07-07 62.94.51.88 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-09-22 Dunbur 1 (1/0) 2006-10-30 137.224.222.5 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-12-10 141.151.178.79 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-03-02 Leflyman 1 (0/1) 2007-03-22 60.234.252.187 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-05-10 Lord Terminus 1 (1/0) 2007-08-07 24.196.133.190 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-10-04 24.86.252.26 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-10-10 76.180.58.249 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-01-01 Nm5mini 1 (0/1) 2008-01-03 Wurdnurd 1 (1/0) 2008-01-30 AndrewHowse 1 (1/0) 2008-02-06 86.95.241.164 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-02-21 70.108.97.105 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-03-01 XLinkBot 1 (1/0) 2008-03-02 76.19.197.201 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-06-10 ENeville 1 (1/0) 2008-06-24 72.192.145.55 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-08-28 24.196.148.220 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-09-24 70.81.124.169 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-11-02 Galoubet 1 (0/1) 2008-11-11 THEN WHO WAS PHONE? 1 (0/1) 2008-12-11 64.180.177.244 (anon) 1 (0/1) 2002-02-25 75.33.225.194 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-12-22 Olivier 1 (1/0) 2002-10-14 Gianfranco 1 (1/0) 2002-11-02 70.128.119.72 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-08-26 Zundark 1 (0/1) 2002-12-24 Axisfan 1 (1/0) 2009-08-30 217.5.114.149 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2003-04-14 Evil saltine 1 (0/1) 2003-09-29 Zoicon5 1 (0/1) 2003-11-25 212.100.182.230 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2004-03-20 Plauz 1 (1/0) 2004-08-21 Timwi 1 (0/1) 2004-09-07 Snowdog 1 (0/1) 2004-10-03 Patrick 1 (0/1) 2004-12-25 195.70.48.242 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-01-13 195.75.161.62 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-06-03 KaiserbBot 1 (0/1) 2005-12-01 CBDunkerson 1 (0/1) 2005-12-06 Luzian 1 (0/1) 2006-02-19 Dreadstar 1 (1/0) 2006-04-18 Lestercrafton 1 (1/0) 2006-04-26 Gaius Cornelius 1 (0/1) 2006-05-05 Rayfield 1 (1/0) 2006-08-16 ![]() |
The result was delete. notability is derived from demonstrating sources and this hasnt happened so the delete votes outweigh the keep arguments Spartaz Humbug! 21:59, 19 September 2009 (UTC)
The only reference is a forum post, and all the links in the article are to sites that sell these things. Not notable enough for inclusion, and borderline advertising Pattont/c 13:21, 6 September 2009 (UTC)
Behaviorology
3 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 4 Creator: Greg987 Nominator: Melchoir
Greg987 21 (19/2) 2009-09-06 Melchoir 2 (2/0) 2009-08-25 Abductive 1 (1/0) 2009-09-02 Ikip 1 (1/0) 2009-09-07 ![]() |
The result was delete. The consensus of the editors here is to delete the article at this time. Since the creator has shown an interest creating a viable article, I have userfied this at his user page for improvement by interested parties. Xymmax So let it be written So let it be done 16:18, 10 September 2009 (UTC)
"Behaviorology" is already an uncommon term in the literature, and this article focuses on a fringe usage. Compare, e.g. [2] versus [3]. Melchoir (talk) 16:54, 25 August 2009 (UTC)
Black Kite: I see now that I put my response to DGG in the wrong place. Sorry about that! Greg987 (talk) 03:17, 2 September 2009 (UTC)
Bennington Triangle
4 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 59 Creator: Joe Durwin Nominator: Simonm223
Milowent 10 (9/1) 2009-09-03 Simonm223 7 (7/0) 2009-09-03 Joe Durwin 5 (5/0) 2005-05-17 158.65.178.191 (anon) 5 (5/0) 2008-04-26 Cbvt 4 (4/0) 2006-06-25 The Special Education Squad 4 (4/0) 2007-12-02 Ilongstaff 4 (4/0) 2008-12-03 Ridgerunner12 3 (2/1) 2008-12-15 Wackymacs 3 (3/0) 2005-06-03 Chr.K. 3 (2/1) 2006-09-06 Nima Baghaei 3 (2/1) 2007-04-15 Fang Aili 2 (1/1) 2006-01-23 208.81.93.210 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-10-23 Mike Rosoft 2 (2/0) 2005-05-29 Hooperbloob 2 (2/0) 2006-02-21 NickJones 2 (2/0) 2008-05-06 Student7 2 (2/0) 2009-09-04 92.236.67.81 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2009-03-02 Pioneer2000 2 (2/0) 2009-04-28 67.40.228.186 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-05-17 71.35.66.200 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-05-28 Marcika 1 (0/1) 2006-02-19 DabMachine 1 (0/1) 2006-02-24 Ken Gallager 1 (1/0) 2006-05-30 Downstream 1 (1/0) 2006-06-10 Rymoda 1 (1/0) 2006-10-12 Xinoph 1 (0/1) 2006-11-13 Cydebot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2006-12-14 John Vandenberg 1 (0/1) 2007-02-08 Veesicle 1 (1/0) 2007-03-14 Storm05 1 (1/0) 2007-04-12 Joel7687 1 (0/1) 2007-08-09 75.68.215.15 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-10-25 Nathanielpalmer 1 (1/0) 2007-11-24 148.122.178.221 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-12-02 Iridescent 1 (0/1) 2008-05-03 GeneralBelly 1 (0/1) 2008-06-13 130.70.150.172 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-09-09 Lightbot 1 (1/0) 2008-10-05 CarsracBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2009-02-17 SmackBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2009-04-07 Dougweller 1 (1/0) 2009-09-02 Blueboar 1 (1/0) 2009-09-03 Ron Ritzman 1 (1/0) 2009-09-10 The Singing Badger 1 (1/0) 2005-05-17 Dancarney 1 (1/0) 2006-02-21 RussBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2006-02-25 STBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2006-10-15 Totnesmartin 1 (1/0) 2006-11-17 CmdrObot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2007-01-13 172.176.74.198 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-02-10 Betacommand 1 (0/1) 2007-03-21 217.208.94.161 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-09-16 Rhys12 1 (0/1) 2007-10-26 DumZiBoT (bot) 1 (0/1) 2008-02-06 89.142.134.89 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-04-07 It Is Me Here 1 (0/1) 2008-09-09 151.151.73.171 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-10-13 XLinkBot 1 (1/0) 2008-12-15 ![]() |
The result was keep. (non-admin closure) Ron Ritzman (talk) 00:37, 10 September 2009 (UTC)
No non-primary verifiable sources. No sources less than 28 years old. No indication listed references contain evidence of notability. Simonm223 (talk) 15:24, 3 September 2009 (UTC)
Globe-Pequot, 1997
Black African genetic contribution to the population of the European continent
5 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 6 Creator: SOPHIAN Nominator: Dougweller
SOPHIAN 11 (11/0) 2009-09-05 Ikip 1 (0/1) 2009-09-06 Dennisthe2 1 (1/0) 2009-09-08 Dougweller 1 (1/0) 2009-09-05 SmackBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2009-09-06 Steve 1 (1/0) 2009-09-08 ![]() |
The result was delete. \ Backslash Forwardslash / (talk) 12:11, 12 September 2009 (UTC)
POV fork of Genetic history of Europe and African admixture in Europe. Dougweller (talk) 11:15, 5 September 2009 (UTC)
Computer TakeBack Campaign
6 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 12 Creator: Seckelberry Nominator: Mufka
Tsmith52 5 (4/1) 2009-09-01 SmackBot (bot) 2 (0/2) 2008-11-03 Cybercobra 2 (0/2) 2009-09-05 Seckelberry 1 (1/0) 2007-10-10 Anarchangel 1 (1/0) 2009-08-22 Pascal666 1 (1/0) 2009-08-23 Alan Liefting 1 (1/0) 2009-09-05 Yeeshenhao 1 (1/0) 2007-12-13 Mufka 1 (1/0) 2009-08-15 ÐлекÑандрВв 1 (1/0) 2009-08-23 DASonnenfeld 1 (1/0) 2009-08-30 TomCat4680 1 (1/0) 2009-09-05 ![]() |
The result was delete. slight consensus towards deleting. Article doesn't have any strong refs nor have they been provided. In other words, it appears to be notable for a single event only. Thus, deleting with no prejudice against creation if/when reliable sources are found. tedder (talk) 07:02, 10 September 2009 (UTC)
Non-notable recycling initiative. No sources support notability. -- Mufka (u) (t) (c) 20:08, 15 August 2009 (UTC)
Elaine Marley
7 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 100 Creator: 81.250.188.208 Nominator: EEMIV
Pictureuploader 10 (10/0) 2008-06-26 62.74.5.26 (anon) 10 (10/0) 2004-12-31 A Nobody 8 (8/0) 2009-09-06 76.67.136.157 (anon) 6 (6/0) 2009-07-05 Maester mensch 5 (1/4) 2006-09-06 Shantih1 5 (4/1) 2008-09-04 Kung Fu Man 5 (5/0) 2009-09-06 69.115.34.186 (anon) 5 (5/0) 2007-01-14 68.225.4.35 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2006-07-24 LaukkuTheGreit 4 (4/0) 2009-09-06 Sailor Angel 4 (3/1) 2007-09-18 The Prince of Darkness 4 (4/0) 2009-06-30 DynSkeet 3 (1/2) 2005-05-22 Jack Merridew 3 (3/0) 2009-09-07 Kuralyov 3 (1/2) 2005-09-09 62.74.7.157 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2005-05-18 87.244.91.53 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-02-13 EEMIV 2 (2/0) 2009-09-06 Glaurung 2 (1/1) 2005-04-13 Matthew Auger 2 (0/2) 2006-04-11 Chariset 2 (2/0) 2006-08-23 24.210.64.174 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-05-28 SmackBot (bot) 2 (0/2) 2009-08-18 203.125.109.131 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2005-04-04 Poulsen 2 (1/1) 2006-03-02 WoodlandMan 2 (2/0) 2006-03-15 200.55.74.206 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2006-08-19 68.84.175.166 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-01-03 66.90.60.130 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-11-08 12.42.154.40 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-06-17 RussBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2008-11-27 Tassedethe 1 (0/1) 2009-01-25 Fenwick221 1 (1/0) 2009-04-18 86.174.124.26 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-06-01 Immblueversion 1 (1/0) 2009-06-07 87.244.66.142 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-06-10 JDspeeder1 1 (0/1) 2009-07-01 Woohookitty 1 (0/1) 2009-07-07 Clerks 1 (0/1) 2009-07-14 Smurfy 1 (1/0) 2009-07-16 76.172.154.19 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-07-23 Martin451 1 (0/1) 2009-07-27 68.187.107.88 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-08-11 81.250.188.208 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2004-06-28 DSisyphBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2009-08-29 Farside 1 (0/1) 2004-08-08 Schneelocke 1 (1/0) 2004-09-10 Jclemens 1 (1/0) 2009-09-06 62.74.4.195 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2004-12-31 Joshk 1 (1/0) 2005-01-08 83.235.17.156 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-03-28 Franzeska 1 (0/1) 2005-04-05 Supermorff 1 (1/0) 2005-04-19 Pearle (bot) 1 (1/0) 2005-06-23 Destroyer of evil 1 (0/1) 2005-10-01 24.57.155.23 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-12-19 Gurch 1 (0/1) 2006-02-27 JiFish 1 (1/0) 2006-03-15 66.93.144.171 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-07-27 24.20.117.38 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-07-29 Meeples 1 (1/0) 2006-08-03 86.128.175.221 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-08-18 84.208.100.247 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-10-29 202.168.103.248 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-11-26 80.178.62.33 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-12-18 86.6.1.245 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-01-14 Pi72 1 (0/1) 2007-02-01 212.114.250.35 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-02-17 200.62.17.130 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-03-20 76.19.229.2 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-05-22 Minnie Alice 1 (1/0) 2007-05-29 134.93.146.12 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-06-16 159.49.254.2 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-09-28 Marktreut 1 (1/0) 2007-11-14 24.193.77.1 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-03-16 FiercedeitylinkX 1 (1/0) 2008-09-03 Mastertechnician 1 (1/0) 2009-04-11 71.138.242.150 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-06-01 92.1.161.50 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-06-07 Eternal Pink 1 (1/0) 2009-06-26 88.111.0.234 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-07-07 90.242.159.132 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-07-16 75.85.182.136 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-07-18 LinKuFF 1 (1/0) 2009-07-27 190.247.180.30 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-08-11 69.125.113.35 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-08-19 Kimiko 1 (0/1) 2004-07-22 Sisyph 1 (0/1) 2009-08-29 Aris Katsaris 1 (0/1) 2004-08-28 24.211.122.206 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2004-09-15 ImageTagBot (bot) 1 (1/0) 2009-09-06 Telso 1 (0/1) 2005-01-30 142.58.101.46 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-04-12 AtZeuS 1 (0/1) 2005-05-16 Suruena 1 (1/0) 2005-07-18 82.130.160.78 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-08-29 82.252.41.124 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-11-27 Dcandeto 1 (1/0) 2006-03-15 81.151.71.22 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-05-12 Zainker 1 (1/0) 2006-07-24 ![]() |
The result was Keep. There is support for a merge, and some for a redirect, and discussions about this may continue on the article's talk page; but it's quite apparent from this discussion there is a strong consensus that Elaine Marley should be a bluelink on Wikipedia. NAC—S Marshall Talk/Cont 08:19, 13 September 2009 (UTC)
Wholly insignificant minor character. No claim of notability and negligible reference to third-party source. Negligible real-world treatment of the topic; article is a regurgitation of her appearances in several games. Original research on "inconsistencies" in the franchise to boot. --EEMIV (talk) 02:13, 6 September 2009 (UTC)
Merge I'd like to say there's enough development and/or reception information to warrant an article out there, but really...there doesn't seem to be. I could see Daphne from Dragon's Lair ending up more plausible for an article to be honest.--Kung Fu Man (talk) 17:45, 6 September 2009 (UTC)
Elvis's Twin Sister
8 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 3 Creator: Francium12 Nominator: Biruitorul
Sherurcij 4 (4/0) 2009-09-09 Francium12 2 (2/0) 2009-09-04 Biruitorul 1 (1/0) 2009-08-28 ![]() |
The result was no consensus. Closing without prejudice against re-nomination. Skomorokh 01:18, 11 September 2009 (UTC)
The article doesn't assert any notability for this poem, so we're left to guess (from the template) that the creator considers it notable because it's included in the AQA Anthology. The fact that it's in the anthology is already indicated in the article on the anthology; the fact that certain British pupils are required to study this poem does not confer inherent notability on it or justify a separate article. Simply being in an anthology is not a substitute for the "significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject" requirement of WP:GNG. - Biruitorul Talk 23:24, 28 August 2009 (UTC)
Graphical methods of finding polynomial roots
9 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 24 Creator: Nassim Chloe Eghtebas Nominator: Gandalf61
Nassim Chloe Eghtebas 190 (188/2) 2009-08-01 Michael Hardy 23 (22/1) 2009-09-08 Colonel Warden 23 (12/11) 2009-09-09 96.251.20.166 (anon) 10 (10/0) 2009-07-21 Verbal 7 (7/0) 2009-09-07 Gandalf61 7 (7/0) 2009-09-07 TeamQuaternion 6 (6/0) 2009-09-08 Hrafn 5 (5/0) 2009-09-07 96.251.20.240 (anon) 5 (5/0) 2009-07-21 Abductive 3 (3/0) 2009-09-07 GTBacchus 2 (2/0) 2009-09-08 Ikip 2 (2/0) 2009-09-06 Cardamon 2 (2/0) 2009-09-07 96.251.20.238 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-07-21 96.251.20.222 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-07-23 96.251.20.231 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-07-30 Malcolmxl5 1 (0/1) 2009-08-28 Qwfp 1 (1/0) 2009-09-03 SmackBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2009-09-07 96.251.20.167 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-07-24 Erik9bot (bot) 1 (1/0) 2009-08-12 Spinningspark 1 (1/0) 2009-09-06 Bongomatic 1 (0/1) 2009-09-07 Johnuniq 1 (0/1) 2009-09-09 ![]() |
The result was no consensus. The article was changed significantly in the middle of the AfD, so many of the earlier comments can't be properly applied to the article as it stands now. The comments surrounding the most recent version appear to be heading towards keeping the article, yet there was such amount of contention surrounding a few points (such as the relevance of WP:HOWTO) that make me uncomfortable with a keep closure. No consensus seems like an optimal closure as it satisfies the recent keep votes yet takes into account the unusual circumstances in regards to the significant improvement and the remaining concerns by those asking for deletion. \ Backslash Forwardslash / (talk) 12:43, 10 September 2009 (UTC)
![]() | Please stay calm and civil while commenting or presenting evidence, and do not make personal attacks. Be patient when approaching solutions to any issues. If consensus is not reached, other solutions exist to draw attention and ensure that more editors mediate or comment on the dispute. |
Unsourced original research. Contested prod. A previous version of the article contained the sentence "Plotting the imaginary roots using empty circle in the Cartesian coordinate system is something new I am proposing" so was obviously OR. This sentence has been removed by subsequent edits, but contents of article have not been substantially changed and no sources have been provided to demonstrate it is not OR. Gandalf61 (talk) 09:14, 3 September 2009 (UTC)
Note that during this discussion the article was moved to Graphical methods of finding polynomial roots. Title, topic and contents are now completely different from the nominated version. The original (and still unsourced) contents of the article were moved to its talk page and so effectively removed from Wikipedia article space. Gandalf61 (talk) 10:18, 6 September 2009 (UTC)
I have requested input from WikiProject Mathematics for this discussion. - 2/0 (cont.) 03:07, 6 September 2009 (UTC)
Why do you think your instincts about what's likely, or what's useful, are going to be better than the instincts of actual working mathematicians? How many absurd claims will you make before you start doing your homework on these topics?
The How-to issue is worth thinking about. However, your other claims... (1) The method does work. (2) The method is used by real mathematicians and real math students. (3) Complex solutions do have concrete physical meanings. (4) Obtaining approximate solutions is useful and does happen in both pure and applied contexts. (5) Having a graph without an equation is as common as dirt; it's how experimental science always works.
What are you going to claim next, Abductive? I recommend you stick to the "How-to" argument and stop pretending you know what goes on in mathematics. You've made it painfully and repeatedly clear that you don't. Start asking questions instead of making wrong assertions. -GTBacchus(talk) 08:39, 10 September 2009 (UTC)
Seriously, though, this discussion raises an interesting question. I've known this method of locating complex zeros since middle school - where did I learn it? It's not in the College Algebra textbook from which I teach today. Most books at that level that I've seen don't address any kind of geometric understanding of complex numbers; they're treated in an entirely algebraic manner, with no notion of a complex plane sticking out from the page. It's a shame really, because the visual approach probably would help a lot of students. I show fellow grad students this, though, and they've never seen it! Bizarre.
I'd like to see the method extended to roots of cubics... -GTBacchus(talk) 20:38, 7 September 2009 (UTC)
In parallel to your statement above, your argument has changed from "you can't actually use this method", to "What are complex (or as you call them, "imaginary", although none of the examples we've looked at have pure imaginary roots) good for, anyway?" Wow. I'm sorry, Abductive, but that's sad.
Let me clue you in a bit: When a system of differential equations has as an eigenvalue (6.3 + 2.3i) that means the system evolves by growing at a rate of e^6.3, while oscillating at a rate of 2pi/2.3. I was kind of assuming you knew that — my bad. -GTBacchus(talk) 19:25, 9 September 2009 (UTC)
If you want to know whether a method will be useful for math students, why not ask some math teachers? -GTBacchus(talk) 07:50, 10 September 2009 (UTC)
Comment Moving away from this specific article, some uses of graphical methods are:
Editing break
10 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 0 Creator: Nassim Chloe Eghtebas Nominator: Gandalf61
![]() |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Editing break
Editing break 2
11 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 0 Creator: Nassim Chloe Eghtebas Nominator: Gandalf61
![]() |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Editing break 2
Jean Patrick Hein
12 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 10 Creator: Braag Nominator: Donnie Park
Braag 4 (4/0) 2007-06-13 ChrJahnsen 4 (3/1) 2009-04-13 Donnie Park 3 (2/1) 2009-09-02 41.17.68.173 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-09-22 SmackBot (bot) 1 (1/0) 2007-08-20 Lightbot 1 (1/0) 2008-09-19 Download 1 (0/1) 2009-04-05 88.102.148.34 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-05-01 Drdisque 1 (1/0) 2007-06-13 88TSI Rob 1 (1/0) 2008-05-24 ![]() |
The result was redirect to Molson_Indy_Vancouver#Deaths. Lankiveil (speak to me) 23:46, 11 September 2009 (UTC)
I would love to redirect this to the 1990 Molson Indy Vancouver article, but the trouble is does it exist, hence my nomination. Also my other reason is failure of WP:BLP guidelines. Donnie Park (talk) 15:51, 2 September 2009 (UTC)
Hela metal
13 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 9 Creator: Julian Grebe Nominator: Prolog
Julian Grebe 41 (37/4) 2009-09-04 ThePaintedOne 8 (8/0) 2009-09-03 Elizabeth Bathory 2 (1/1) 2009-09-04 Cyborgpissa 1 (0/1) 2009-08-26 Fribbler 1 (1/0) 2009-08-27 Fences and windows 1 (1/0) 2009-09-01 Blackmetalbaz 1 (1/0) 2009-09-03 Woohookitty 1 (0/1) 2009-08-26 Prolog 1 (1/0) 2009-09-03 ![]() |
The result was delete. Cirt (talk) 20:10, 11 September 2009 (UTC)
The subject does not seem to meet WP:N and WP:V. The sources in the article are unreliable and/or do not contain any significant coverage (and are used very dubiously as well, as if just thrown in there somewhere). Nothing on Google News and there are no reliable sources among the few Google hits either. This seems to be just another case where a (barely notable) band claims to have invented a new genre. Prolog (talk) 06:10, 3 September 2009 (UTC)
LeChuck
15 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 100 Creator: 81.250.188.208 Nominator: EEMIV
69.115.34.186 (anon) 200 (200/0) 2008-08-23 Darknessofhearts 50 (50/0) 2007-09-29 The Prince of Darkness 43 (42/1) 2008-09-15 69.115.39.222 (anon) 36 (36/0) 2009-08-28 Shantih1 11 (10/1) 2007-10-24 Eaglizard 6 (5/1) 2007-10-24 Valley2city 6 (6/0) 2009-01-15 24.228.18.66 (anon) 6 (6/0) 2009-07-06 Pictureuploader 5 (5/0) 2005-08-12 129.2.201.50 (anon) 5 (5/0) 2006-09-09 Jack Merridew 5 (5/0) 2009-09-07 Cydebot (bot) 4 (0/4) 2007-04-02 69.170.219.179 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2006-08-08 SmackBot (bot) 4 (0/4) 2008-10-11 Maester mensch 4 (2/2) 2006-09-06 12.144.50.194 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2007-06-04 60.234.136.37 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2007-08-26 Gladrius 3 (0/3) 2007-12-01 Pele Merengue 3 (3/0) 2008-09-18 88.77.136.4 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2009-06-02 Eccentricned 3 (3/0) 2006-08-19 Purple Rose 3 (1/2) 2005-06-02 DynSkeet 3 (0/3) 2006-05-24 76.67.136.157 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2009-07-06 MoogleDan 2 (2/0) 2007-01-17 81.145.240.132 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-07-10 130.15.199.171 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-01-17 142.213.176.78 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-08-01 DaveJB 2 (1/1) 2009-08-27 213.140.18.131 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-10-31 65.28.71.28 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2009-01-05 78.20.106.214 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2009-02-18 Amedeus 2 (0/2) 2006-10-02 90.200.106.120 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2009-08-23 Tabletop 2 (0/2) 2007-06-04 Kuralyov 2 (2/0) 2006-07-07 Ketiltrout 2 (0/2) 2007-05-17 Dark T Zeratul 2 (0/2) 2007-06-03 MikeVitale 2 (0/2) 2007-09-04 67.161.46.197 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2006-11-25 Pikawil 2 (2/0) 2006-06-26 Poulsen 2 (1/1) 2006-03-02 Matthew Auger 2 (0/2) 2006-04-11 Thanos6 2 (1/1) 2006-12-19 Prophaniti 2 (2/0) 2008-10-10 206.126.81.172 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-12-19 Eternal Pink 2 (2/0) 2009-03-13 213.190.105.198 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2006-08-06 75.19.34.254 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2009-07-13 139.168.124.69 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-01-23 Pi72 1 (0/1) 2007-02-01 81.250.188.208 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2004-06-28 82.216.206.91 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-02-11 Farside 1 (0/1) 2004-08-08 24.16.217.245 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-02-21 68.35.125.52 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2004-08-09 71.192.40.35 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-02-28 24.211.122.206 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2004-09-15 Piemanmoo 1 (1/0) 2007-03-22 Jonathunder 1 (0/1) 2005-01-08 Osirusr 1 (0/1) 2007-05-14 Hathawayc 1 (0/1) 2005-04-13 Kusma 1 (1/0) 2007-05-20 Supermorff 1 (1/0) 2005-04-19 Whitetigah 1 (0/1) 2005-04-27 164.156.231.55 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-06-29 62.74.5.166 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-05-17 Pearle (bot) 1 (1/0) 2005-06-23 86.140.204.195 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-07-12 Suruena 1 (1/0) 2005-07-18 81.76.113.202 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-08-05 82.130.160.78 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-08-29 Destroyer of evil 1 (0/1) 2005-10-07 Cooksey 1 (0/1) 2005-12-09 88.91.99.235 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-09-29 68.189.78.42 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-01-22 Cheeser1 1 (0/1) 2007-10-12 Jaysbro 1 (1/0) 2006-01-23 Gaius Cornelius 1 (0/1) 2007-10-20 198.105.45.201 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-01-26 68.7.77.46 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-02-23 60.227.26.125 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-03-24 134.93.146.108 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-01-26 65.27.172.145 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-04-14 81.110.108.151 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-04-29 12.16.112.198 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-04-23 Marktreut 1 (1/0) 2006-04-26 FiercedeitylinkX 1 (1/0) 2008-09-03 208.7.93.138 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-05-22 Alex Klotz 1 (0/1) 2006-07-10 Dimadozen 1 (1/0) 2008-11-08 Orz 1 (1/0) 2006-07-14 68.72.132.174 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-07-21 Legobot II (bot) 1 (0/1) 2009-01-17 Eurosong 1 (0/1) 2006-08-06 ShelfSkewed 1 (1/0) 2009-03-22 Dutchtica 1 (0/1) 2006-08-06 68.103.218.84 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-08-06 LittleOldMe 1 (1/0) 2009-06-04 Warreed 1 (0/1) 2009-06-08 ![]() |
The result was keep, without prejudice against merging should local consensus so decide. Arguments to delete here were weak – variants on WP:RUBBISH, WP:NOEFFORT, WP:PROBLEMS and WP:JNN, but those advocating keep did so primarily on the basis of an important rather than verifiable conception of notability. Ultimately, the strength of the identified sources will determine whether or not a thoroughly verified, reliably sourced description of the topic is sustainable as a stand-alone article. Skomorokh 21:58, 12 September 2009 (UTC)
No assertion of notability. Insignificant references to reliable sources. Is essentially a regurgitation of plot summary covered in games' individual articles. Article has been tagged for clean-up for almost two years, with negligible improvement. --EEMIV (talk) 21:46, 5 September 2009 (UTC)
Also see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Herman Toothrot, which includes Stan (Monkey Island). Not very good for the nominator to fail to mention the related nominations. Fences&Windows 15:02, 6 September 2009 (UTC)
List of riots
16 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 100 Creator: DavidLevinson Nominator: Aaaronsmith
Mcanmoocanu 84 (84/0) 2009-06-25 Lokifer 39 (37/2) 2006-06-19 Phil5329 22 (19/3) 2009-09-04 DanTD 20 (20/0) 2009-07-14 204.52.215.107 (anon) 17 (17/0) 2007-03-10 MadMax 16 (13/3) 2006-10-26 NorsemanII 16 (16/0) 2008-07-02 209.213.71.78 (anon) 15 (15/0) 2005-06-16 R9tgokunks 12 (12/0) 2007-12-14 Superfopp 10 (10/0) 2009-09-01 138.88.20.85 (anon) 10 (10/0) 2005-06-29 86.165.9.125 (anon) 10 (10/0) 2009-04-04 219.23.5.48 (anon) 10 (10/0) 2009-05-24 Alice...in wiki 10 (9/1) 2008-01-16 DavidLevinson 9 (3/6) 2005-10-14 141.156.86.235 (anon) 7 (7/0) 2005-12-10 Dermo69 7 (7/0) 2007-02-28 141.156.82.254 (anon) 7 (7/0) 2005-11-05 OOODDD 7 (7/0) 2008-05-14 SmackBot (bot) 7 (0/7) 2009-05-24 Aaaronsmith 6 (5/1) 2009-09-03 Jengod 6 (6/0) 2004-02-19 Joseph Solis in Australia 6 (0/6) 2009-02-23 25 6 (2/4) 2005-04-11 86.166.126.48 (anon) 5 (5/0) 2009-05-25 141.156.81.92 (anon) 5 (5/0) 2005-12-14 141.156.80.119 (anon) 5 (5/0) 2005-05-07 Jhamez84 5 (2/3) 2006-10-24 138.88.19.85 (anon) 5 (5/0) 2005-11-05 Rich Farmbrough 4 (3/1) 2009-08-19 Brekass 4 (4/0) 2008-04-24 66.31.254.88 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2006-06-10 Alfonsino2 4 (4/0) 2007-09-06 Stevietheman 4 (4/0) 2006-09-10 137.44.1.200 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2007-10-08 138.88.26.68 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2007-12-09 81.151.185.2 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2005-12-16 Elwrucko 4 (4/0) 2008-02-03 87.54.33.209 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2008-02-05 141.156.83.106 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2006-03-29 Neutronbomb 4 (4/0) 2007-05-22 KNewman 4 (4/0) 2005-09-03 126.113.89.34 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2008-06-19 24.129.60.12 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2004-09-17 Polynova 3 (1/2) 2005-05-30 38.116.204.34 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2005-12-15 66.213.16.180 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2005-12-19 84.120.189.43 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2007-12-23 83.95.218.220 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2007-05-19 12.216.100.95 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2007-04-07 137.222.184.207 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2006-03-06 Hugowannahoogie 3 (3/0) 2008-04-07 86.138.252.99 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2009-04-13 Jwise77 3 (3/0) 2006-05-16 80.7.238.150 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2009-05-19 L'emeutier concupiscent 3 (2/1) 2008-04-29 Philipvanlidth 3 (3/0) 2009-05-28 213.247.237.135 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2005-11-05 81.153.163.121 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2009-07-14 Mapsax 3 (3/0) 2007-12-20 SteveSims 3 (0/3) 2008-08-10 137.122.252.183 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2005-12-11 141.156.84.107 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2005-12-12 Kransky 3 (3/0) 2006-11-08 Googlemeister 3 (3/0) 2009-09-09 91.125.72.100 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2008-10-14 203.129.207.10 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2008-10-21 Donetruk 3 (3/0) 2007-12-21 Acumensch 3 (3/0) 2007-12-19 71.57.161.219 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2007-03-20 71.140.116.6 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2008-03-04 199.174.65.57 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2005-07-08 84.238.69.185 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2008-04-13 24.181.30.207 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2005-08-12 79.75.191.157 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2009-05-04 Pubdog 3 (1/2) 2009-06-10 200.35.231.172 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2005-11-12 138.88.26.128 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2005-11-19 Jackbrown 2 (0/2) 2008-07-17 138.88.22.211 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2005-12-02 74.220.228.170 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-10-29 Agendum 2 (2/0) 2004-01-13 N2e 2 (0/2) 2007-11-28 219.90.139.212 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2009-08-09 24.89.100.81 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2006-11-04 90.204.117.135 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-11-12 ShaneAu 2 (0/2) 2005-12-12 Docu 2 (0/2) 2009-04-20 B-Machine 2 (2/0) 2009-08-29 128.8.77.67 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2005-12-13 173.55.0.225 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2009-09-04 Mjolnir1984 2 (0/2) 2005-12-14 75.117.12.162 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-10-19 122.49.170.240 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-12-08 83.92.174.36 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-11-06 64.168.29.119 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2005-01-09 Neutrality 2 (1/1) 2008-12-06 Demerzel 2 (0/2) 2007-02-23 Salishsea 2 (2/0) 2006-02-11 Google fac 2 (2/0) 2008-12-14 ![]() |
The result was keep. Skomorokh 03:39, 10 September 2009 (UTC)
While the idea is perfectly acceptable (a listing of a type of event) the sheer magnitude of incompleteness makes the article functionally less useful than no article at all and depending on the Wiki user to find the information they want w a more complex search than just going to one article that implies an accuracy it does not have. Nomination fixed for Aaaronsmith (talk · contribs); no position on the merits myself. Tim Song (talk) 01:26, 3 September 2009 (UTC)
List of current ISKCON sannyasis
17 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 6 Creator: Tintomat0es Nominator: Wikidas
Tintomat0es 15 (13/2) 2009-09-08 Wikidas 5 (4/1) 2009-09-08 UltraMagnus 1 (1/0) 2009-09-08 Calaka 1 (0/1) 2009-09-05 RHaworth 1 (0/1) 2009-09-07 SmackBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2009-09-09 ![]() |
The result was no consensus. Sandstein 04:11, 16 September 2009 (UTC)
Delete - WP:OR list based of mostly non-notables, not supported by decent sources. A fork from other lists of ISKCON members. Reference is made to blogs sites and otherwise disputed sources. Wikidas© 08:16, 8 September 2009 (UTC)
List of stock characters in science fiction
18 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 66 Creator: Breed Zona Nominator: YeshuaDavid
WarpZone 29 (13/16) 2007-05-04 Colonel Warden 8 (7/1) 2009-09-04 Waninge 5 (3/2) 2008-03-25 Breed Zona 4 (2/2) 2006-09-21 71.230.34.38 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2007-02-17 Iisryan 2 (0/2) 2007-03-25 124.177.70.28 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-05-22 Richard Arthur Norton (1958- ) 2 (2/0) 2009-09-02 Goldfritha 2 (2/0) 2007-05-04 Luigifan 2 (0/2) 2007-01-22 4.155.57.6 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-03-19 24.215.184.168 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-03-28 203.173.5.75 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-04-02 70.67.226.232 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-05-03 SmackBot (bot) 2 (0/2) 2007-09-29 EEMIV 2 (2/0) 2007-08-20 209.166.86.99 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-10-27 JohnnyMrNinja 2 (2/0) 2008-05-21 Yobmod 2 (2/0) 2009-01-09 24.5.241.109 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-08-26 24.96.77.191 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-09-16 Pegship 1 (0/1) 2006-09-29 68.111.165.55 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-10-15 Lainagier 1 (0/1) 2006-12-14 MegX 1 (0/1) 2006-12-31 68.160.67.15 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-03-14 Cayzle 1 (0/1) 2007-03-29 Egomaniac 1 (1/0) 2007-04-03 Pretzelpaws 1 (1/0) 2007-04-12 71.240.100.119 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-05-02 Angmering 1 (0/1) 2007-05-09 CmdrObot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2007-05-30 Byeee 1 (1/0) 2007-06-26 71.92.71.247 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-07-07 206.192.18.13 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-08-18 Mike Klaassen 1 (1/0) 2007-09-28 Johnbod 1 (1/0) 2007-10-14 24.24.82.210 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-02-18 AnonMoos 1 (1/0) 2008-03-12 90.207.59.122 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-03-24 Stefanomione 1 (0/1) 2008-06-14 Fayenatic london 1 (0/1) 2008-10-31 190.133.131.131 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-01-01 Gothbag 1 (1/0) 2009-07-19 Chariset 1 (1/0) 2006-09-09 Chris Buckey 1 (0/1) 2006-09-19 69.175.49.202 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-10-04 Theknightofdarkness 1 (1/0) 2006-12-07 James.S 1 (0/1) 2006-12-18 Saber girl08 1 (0/1) 2007-03-12 Lilledrage 1 (1/0) 2007-04-07 124.186.231.238 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-04-15 Rjwilmsi 1 (0/1) 2007-05-25 Closenplay 1 (0/1) 2007-06-13 64.131.248.59 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-07-04 Ewlyahoocom 1 (0/1) 2007-08-21 Cydebot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2007-10-11 NaminesPetals 1 (1/0) 2007-12-27 Harryboyles 1 (0/1) 2008-02-18 86.132.19.13 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-03-20 Iamthedeus 1 (1/0) 2008-05-19 AnnaFrance 1 (0/1) 2008-06-13 Jc37 1 (0/1) 2008-10-16 Legobot II (bot) 1 (0/1) 2009-01-10 YeshuaDavid 1 (1/0) 2009-09-01 Chick Bowen 1 (1/0) 2009-09-09 ![]() |
The result was no consensus. It's clear that this list not only needs work but clearer criteria for inclusion. But no consensus to delete it exists at this time. Chick Bowen 02:35, 9 September 2009 (UTC)
Delete With respect, this is hardly a definitive list of stock characters, and very much open to debate. The entire list is based on one source, The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction, and Wikipedia would do much better to have an article on this than just quoting entries like "computer", "lotus-eaters", "Hitler" and "God" without any explaination. YeshuaDavid • Talk • 17:46, 1 September 2009 (UTC)
Cindi Love
19 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 27 Creator: Sjharte Nominator: Serpentduv
Aristophanes68 19 (19/0) 2009-09-05 Serpentduv 14 (6/8) 2009-09-05 Bilby 12 (10/2) 2009-09-07 Sjharte 5 (2/3) 2006-09-23 Cydebot (bot) 2 (0/2) 2008-09-22 DTOx 2 (0/2) 2007-11-07 Cameron Scott 2 (2/0) 2009-09-05 Bearcat 1 (1/0) 2005-10-30 ArglebargleIV 1 (1/0) 2006-02-03 Myleslong 1 (0/1) 2006-05-03 Yonmei 1 (0/1) 2006-08-21 Severa 1 (1/0) 2007-09-28 Andrew c 1 (0/1) 2007-11-04 Asarelah 1 (1/0) 2009-07-24 Woohookitty 1 (0/1) 2009-08-15 Zazaban 1 (1/0) 2009-09-05 SmackBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2009-09-05 Benjiboi 1 (1/0) 2009-09-05 Rich Farmbrough 1 (0/1) 2005-09-26 Bluemoose 1 (1/0) 2006-01-01 Gardar Rurak 1 (1/0) 2006-04-07 Badbilltucker 1 (1/0) 2006-07-28 63.227.41.35 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-11-29 Belovedfreak 1 (1/0) 2007-07-04 82.71.120.62 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-11-03 MetsBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2007-11-07 Lawikitejana 1 (0/1) 2007-11-13 ![]() |
The result was keep. Skomorokh 14:22, 12 September 2009 (UTC)
This person does not meet Wikipedia's noteworthy guidelines. Serpentduv (talk) 08:27, 5 September 2009 (UTC)
Lucky stone
20 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 4 Creator: Brow66dani Nominator: Ironholds
Brow66dani 7 (7/0) 2009-09-07 Uncle G 3 (3/0) 2009-09-07 Ironholds 2 (2/0) 2009-09-06 UltraMagnus 1 (1/0) 2009-09-06 ![]() |
The result was Keep. There is very strong support for a merge to Freshwater drum, but this is not quite unanimous and valid objections have been raised. What is apparent from this discussion is that Lucky stone should not be a redlink on Wikipedia; discussions about a merge can continue on the relevant talk pages. NAC—S Marshall Talk/Cont 08:41, 13 September 2009 (UTC)
fails WP:GNG. Ironholds (talk) 12:19, 6 September 2009 (UTC)
This article could be merged with the article on the Freshwater Drum. However, I believe it merits a stand alone article which could be named either "Lucky Stone" or "Lucky Stones." I have now enumerated various sources which point to the importance of Lucky stones in Ancient Native American Culture and in Modern Culture. Certainly, "lucky stones" merit more importance than recent articles I have read on Wikipedia regarding Pop Culture video games. The otoliths of the Freshwater Drum have been collected for centuries, especially along the main breeding grounds of the Freshwater Drum along the shores of Lake Erie and Red Lake in Wisconsin. Brow66Dani Brow66dani (talk) 13:06, 9 September 2009 (UTC)
It strikes this author that perhaps it is Ethnocentric or Eurocentric to consider that the topic of "lucky stones" is not noteworthy enough to merit its own article when I just read a new article on Wikipedia titled Rick Dancer about a minor celebrity/politician in Oregon (where I currently reside). I will plead guilty to my own ethocentrism as well as the article would be stronger with more research regarding the Native American link to lucky stones. Unfortunately, most references I have found give only vague references to lucky stones having been collected for centuries by Native Americans and that they have been found in "ancient archaeological sites" etc.... I do remember reading one article that gave a specific tribal reference. Others could help me strengthen the article by doing further research as well. The broader point, however, is that lucky stones are artifacts which have been collected for centuries and seem to this writer far more noteworthy than many other articles that appear on Wikipedia. Comments by others?? Brow66Dani 68.118.60.87 (talk) 14:17, 9 September 2009 (UTC) BroDani Brow66dani (talk) 02:46, 10 September 2009 (UTC)
Logan Lynn
21 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 16 Creator: XXSoulSurvivorXx Nominator: Bongomatic
72.85.159.218 (anon) 72 (72/0) 2009-09-01 XXSoulSurvivorXx 32 (32/0) 2009-08-06 Danielquasar 21 (11/10) 2009-08-04 Ttonyb1 16 (13/3) 2009-09-02 PDXProlific 12 (5/7) 2009-09-03 Woohookitty 4 (1/3) 2009-08-06 66.193.40.138 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2009-09-03 RussBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2009-08-02 98.246.173.60 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-08-04 Bongomatic 1 (1/0) 2009-08-31 SmackBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2009-09-02 Per Ardua 1 (1/0) 2009-08-02 BD2412 1 (0/1) 2009-08-05 ThaddeusB 1 (0/1) 2009-08-09 Deb 1 (0/1) 2009-08-31 Benjiboi 1 (1/0) 2009-09-01 ![]() |
The result was keep. There is sufficent consensus from non-SPA accounts to close this AFD for a keep, otherwise there was no consensus for deletion anyways. JForget 22:53, 12 September 2009 (UTC)
![]() | If you came here because someone asked you to, or you read a message on another website, please note that this is not a majority vote, but instead a discussion among Wikipedia contributors. Wikipedia has policies and guidelines regarding the encyclopedia's content, and consensus (agreement) is gauged based on the merits of the arguments, not by counting votes.
However, you are invited to participate and your opinion is welcome. Remember to assume good faith on the part of others and to sign your posts on this page by adding ~~~~ at the end. Note: Comments may be tagged as follows. Suspected single-purpose accounts:((subst:spa|username)) , suspected canvassed users: ((subst:canvassed|username)) , accounts blocked for sockpuppetry: ((subst:csm|username)) or ((subst:csp|username)) |
Non-notable musician. Does not satisfy any relevant notability guideline (WP:GNG or WP:MUSIC). Bongomatic 17:17, 31 August 2009 (UTC)
Relister's Comment': This AFD was relisted despite 5 keep votes so to have more discussion/comments from non possible SPA accounts.JForget 23:01, 6 September 2009 (UTC)
Delete. Does not meet WP:GNG or WP:BAND. Warrior4321 23:42, 6 September 2009 (UTC)
KEEP - well-written and sourced article already exists. Keep it. #REDIRECT Target page name —Preceding unsigned comment added by Astanhope (talk • contribs)
Manon Batiste
22 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 51 Creator: Bwing55543 Nominator: EEMIV
A Nobody 19 (19/0) 2009-09-07 Bwing55543 14 (14/0) 2007-07-25 69.139.228.96 (anon) 11 (11/0) 2008-09-24 129.169.73.216 (anon) 7 (7/0) 2007-05-08 ESommers 5 (5/0) 2007-07-17 Alex 1991 3 (3/0) 2007-04-08 61.94.139.37 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2008-03-10 69.10.203.190 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2008-09-21 24.143.226.138 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2009-03-08 72.224.46.198 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2007-10-12 EEMIV 3 (3/0) 2009-09-07 Colonies Chris 2 (1/1) 2007-10-05 Joowwww 2 (2/0) 2007-08-26 65.255.147.8 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-11-29 156.56.176.131 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-05-12 80.216.166.224 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-10-07 125.163.75.41 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-12-24 Yojimbo501 2 (2/0) 2008-05-17 99.137.21.11 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-06-11 121.151.14.132 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-04-26 OrphanBot (bot) 1 (1/0) 2007-05-02 CmdrObot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2007-06-09 81.82.79.167 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-06-30 Pathbinder 1 (1/0) 2008-03-14 SpellingBot 1 (0/1) 2008-04-01 Randomran 1 (1/0) 2008-05-29 24.94.123.46 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-08-13 68.122.145.187 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-09-12 Rjwilmsi 1 (0/1) 2009-01-05 Semper-Fi 2006 1 (1/0) 2009-07-12 Victory93 1 (1/0) 2009-09-05 Jclemens 1 (1/0) 2009-09-06 Richard Arthur Norton (1958- ) 1 (1/0) 2009-09-08 Kung Fu Man 1 (1/0) 2009-09-09 AlexNewArtBot (bot) 1 (1/0) 2007-03-24 Belovedfreak 1 (0/1) 2007-04-30 Chiafriend12 1 (0/1) 2007-06-13 Captain Phoebus 1 (1/0) 2007-08-24 Scottie theNerd 1 (1/0) 2007-08-26 24.94.122.103 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-01-27 125.163.85.123 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-03-12 210.213.94.146 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-03-17 67.165.212.54 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-05-03 69.10.217.65 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-09-03 201.9.31.160 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-10-05 WiKID Daryl 1 (0/1) 2008-12-11 Shatteredx 1 (1/0) 2009-01-01 216.249.95.247 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-01-21 Mollythemick 1 (0/1) 2009-06-15 SmackBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2009-09-02 86.66.204.73 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-09-08 ![]() |
The result was no consensus. Just too much splitted on notability criteria here. Tip: Please add some references in the second half. That would be helpful in the event of a future AFD (if this happens). JForget 19:49, 14 September 2009 (UTC)
Wholly insignificant character; player's character in the MOH/COD games might as well be nameless avatars. No claim of notability and zero citations to third-party sources (currently, article is referenced only to the games themselves). This is merely a regurgitation of game plot and a listing of "awards" (i.e. military recognitions) garnered by this make-believe fellow. Easily/sufficiently covered in main franchise article. No attempt to address the subject in an encyclopedic manner, undoubtedly because no significant third-party sources responding to/scrutinizing this might-as-well-be-nameless character exist. --EEMIV (talk) 02:11, 6 September 2009 (UTC)
Munchie Strikes Back
23 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 6 Creator: Haidenmeizure Nominator: SebastianHelm
MichaelQSchmidt 6 (6/0) 2009-09-07 SebastianHelm 2 (2/0) 2009-09-09 A Nobody 2 (2/0) 2009-09-07 Haidenmeizure 1 (1/0) 2009-09-05 Pmussler 1 (1/0) 2009-09-06 Evil saltine 1 (1/0) 2009-09-05 ![]() |
The result was Article has been substantially improved; there are no more delete votes. — Preceding unsigned comment added by SebastianHelm (talk • contribs)
Unspeedying deletion. Was incorrectly tagged as A1. It's a terrible start for an article, but it does have some links that show that it has some marginal notability.
Jimmy Patterson
24 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 100 Creator: Luckycharms13 Nominator: EEMIV
ESommers 41 (40/1) 2007-08-26 69.139.228.96 (anon) 29 (29/0) 2008-09-25 209.6.21.129 (anon) 23 (23/0) 2007-05-24 Knight45 20 (15/5) 2007-07-15 209.244.42.156 (anon) 10 (10/0) 2006-11-28 A Nobody 10 (10/0) 2009-09-07 71.248.174.76 (anon) 8 (8/0) 2007-07-03 216.178.91.34 (anon) 8 (8/0) 2007-03-06 0612 8 (8/0) 2006-12-29 BeQuiet! 7 (7/0) 2006-12-19 Scottie theNerd 6 (6/0) 2007-08-19 Bwing55543 6 (6/0) 2007-09-11 146.115.6.194 (anon) 6 (6/0) 2007-10-24 90.242.144.249 (anon) 5 (5/0) 2008-07-08 62.136.202.14 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2007-12-09 68.35.162.25 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2008-05-12 Braden 0.0 4 (4/0) 2009-07-28 65.32.231.204 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2006-12-02 Jack Merridew 3 (3/0) 2009-09-07 Cydebot (bot) 3 (0/3) 2008-10-07 67.165.10.32 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2007-07-15 72.154.79.201 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2007-11-03 216.249.95.247 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2009-01-21 Deathbunny 3 (3/0) 2007-01-08 65.32.231.232 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2007-01-16 Freemarket 3 (0/3) 2007-02-26 SmackBot (bot) 3 (0/3) 2009-09-02 66.244.93.186 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2007-04-24 77.196.62.128 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2009-06-06 68.33.106.229 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2009-06-10 Rjwilmsi 2 (0/2) 2008-08-30 Wbankhead 2 (2/0) 2007-04-07 Bobo192 2 (0/2) 2007-05-24 Mschel 2 (2/0) 2007-05-24 Clyde Miller 2 (2/0) 2007-07-13 Dodopod 2 (2/0) 2007-08-06 Squaretex 2 (1/1) 2007-11-08 71.63.204.22 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-11-14 EEMIV 2 (2/0) 2009-09-06 70.244.174.197 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-05-02 Mr Adequate 2 (2/0) 2007-05-24 67.161.18.205 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-07-15 72.224.46.198 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-10-12 Mentifisto 2 (2/0) 2007-11-03 24.94.122.103 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-01-27 81.158.186.57 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-09-21 Evans1982 1 (0/1) 2008-11-24 72.148.105.178 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-01-04 122.107.122.149 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-02-20 Luckycharms13 1 (1/0) 2006-11-03 89.242.36.129 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-03-02 24.19.81.120 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-04-25 MER-C 1 (1/0) 2006-11-28 Fabrictramp 1 (1/0) 2006-11-28 69.209.138.75 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-07-06 The wub 1 (0/1) 2006-12-12 Semper-Fi 2006 1 (1/0) 2009-07-12 83.85.71.144 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-12-24 85.76.222.91 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-07-26 24.36.74.94 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-12-29 YUL89YYZ 1 (0/1) 2009-07-29 Xdamr 1 (0/1) 2009-08-22 Victory93 1 (1/0) 2009-09-05 Sandstein 1 (1/0) 2007-01-21 Jclemens 1 (1/0) 2009-09-06 74.13.85.134 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-01-27 24.161.113.29 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-03-22 Android Mouse Bot 3 (bot) 1 (1/0) 2007-05-27 66.82.9.74 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-07-07 El Bandano 1 (1/0) 2007-08-28 65.255.147.8 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-11-29 71.185.36.150 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-12-10 80.57.120.194 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-02-06 Kalathalan 1 (0/1) 2008-02-11 Werdan7 1 (0/1) 2008-02-13 Kumioko 1 (1/0) 2008-02-19 65.32.230.26 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-03-12 124.191.61.153 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-05-25 Randomran 1 (1/0) 2008-05-29 SE7 1 (0/1) 2008-07-03 Inwind 1 (0/1) 2008-07-16 Tbsdy lives 1 (1/0) 2008-08-12 74.94.72.193 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-08-14 202.156.14.74 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-08-15 69.10.203.190 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-09-19 86.66.204.23 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-11-14 91.154.71.78 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-12-22 70.208.99.177 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-03-02 Bluebot 1 (1/0) 2006-11-09 24.143.226.138 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-03-08 Andymc 1 (0/1) 2009-05-05 82.32.146.65 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-06-07 76.217.63.236 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-06-16 RobotG (bot) 1 (0/1) 2006-12-11 XLinkBot 1 (1/0) 2009-07-06 85.77.218.179 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-07-19 GreatWhiteNortherner 1 (0/1) 2006-12-25 Thiseye 1 (0/1) 2006-12-31 71.230.99.39 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-08-19 Betacommand 1 (0/1) 2007-01-09 ![]() |
The result was no consensus. \ Backslash Forwardslash / (talk) 00:06, 13 September 2009 (UTC)
Wholly insignificant character; player's character in the MOH/COD games might as well be nameless avatars. No claim of notability and zero citations to any sort of sources. This is merely a list of appearances, gameguide weapons trivia, and a listing of "awards" (i.e. military recognitions) garnered by this make-believe fellow. Easily/sufficiently covered in main franchise article. No attempt to address the subject in an encyclopedic manner, undoubtedly because no significant third-party sources responding to/scrutinizing this might-as-well-be-nameless character exist. --EEMIV (talk) 02:10, 6 September 2009 (UTC)
Sony BDP-S1
25 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 61 Creator: Rdodolak Nominator: Ejfetters
170.211.90.62 (anon) 8 (8/0) 2009-02-25 Rdodolak 5 (5/0) 2007-06-02 Mcrexx 5 (2/3) 2007-08-04 Supra2JZGTE 5 (5/0) 2007-02-09 Guyonphone 3 (1/2) 2007-02-08 Alra111 3 (3/0) 2006-11-09 Ejfetters 3 (3/0) 2009-09-05 Mikeblas 2 (0/2) 2007-01-28 Myscrnnm 2 (2/0) 2007-02-26 Nick 8 2 (1/1) 2007-09-04 219.77.177.115 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-01-17 Wikimatic 2 (2/0) 2008-09-26 Cybercobra 2 (1/1) 2009-09-08 Ikip 2 (2/0) 2009-09-09 Isopropyl 2 (2/0) 2006-05-27 24.136.152.175 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2006-06-25 Ksbrown 2 (0/2) 2006-09-10 66.67.221.61 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2007-05-16 Playstationdude 2 (2/0) 2007-10-03 Joe Chill 2 (2/0) 2009-09-08 68.69.181.185 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-06-20 PerfectStorm 1 (1/0) 2006-06-26 Essexmutant 1 (1/0) 2006-09-10 MarshBot 1 (1/0) 2006-11-07 Quadell 1 (1/0) 2006-11-09 209.128.88.116 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-01-22 68.6.72.147 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-04-18 86.138.51.71 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-05-13 Editore99 1 (1/0) 2007-05-22 WikiBully 1 (1/0) 2007-05-25 Nv8200p 1 (1/0) 2007-05-27 216.192.134.3 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-07-25 CmdrObot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2007-10-16 SmackBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2007-12-14 J.delanoy 1 (1/0) 2008-02-02 Petertorr 1 (0/1) 2008-03-14 JzG 1 (1/0) 2008-04-16 Walter the Frog 1 (0/1) 2008-05-26 NorthernThunder 1 (1/0) 2009-02-19 ClueBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2009-02-25 12.49.139.162 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-08-12 71.158.215.34 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-09-07 Jasonsk287 1 (1/0) 2006-12-10 154.20.45.143 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-01-23 24.244.240.33 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-02-21 0goodiegoodie0 1 (0/1) 2007-03-02 84.163.239.174 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-03-08 Mütze 1 (1/0) 2007-04-30 Rock2e 1 (1/0) 2007-05-25 209.183.34.47 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-06-16 202.43.233.244 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-07-27 Bovineone 1 (1/0) 2007-11-05 Isthisthingworking 1 (0/1) 2007-12-26 SkeletorUK 1 (1/0) 2008-01-21 Seanor3 1 (1/0) 2008-02-27 Gamer007 1 (0/1) 2008-03-28 81.154.143.119 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-05-02 Gogo Dodo 1 (0/1) 2008-05-26 213.138.147.122 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-11-12 71.88.103.98 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-02-20 Stifle 1 (1/0) 2009-08-20 ![]() |
The result was no consensus. Stifle (talk) 08:57, 20 August 2009 (UTC)
I am also nominating the following related pages:
unnotable Blu Ray player models, basically advertisement and reiteration of specs found in instruction manual. There are likely thousands of models of Blu Ray players. Unencyclopedic. Ejfetters (talk) 14:11, 12 August 2009 (UTC)
Tactical frivolity
26 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 38 Creator: 24.189.173.175 Nominator: Skomorokh
24.22.141.252 (anon) 17 (17/0) 2009-09-09 Skomorokh 13 (12/1) 2009-09-06 80.3.64.7 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2004-10-19 ***Ria777 4 (0/4) 2006-08-11 24.189.173.175 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2002-12-29 FeydHuxtable 3 (3/0) 2009-09-09 Sethmahoney 2 (1/1) 2004-09-08 GeoGreg 2 (0/2) 2004-11-23 Cgingold 2 (1/1) 2007-08-25 Dakinijones 2 (0/2) 2008-08-18 82.138.214.1 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2006-10-23 81.6.30.119 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2003-07-16 Cyan 1 (0/1) 2003-09-18 Seth Ilys 1 (0/1) 2004-07-09 Markaci 1 (1/0) 2005-06-21 24.85.226.76 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-11-30 SmackBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2006-06-14 Switchercat 1 (1/0) 2006-09-30 CmdrObot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2007-01-08 84.167.109.145 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2007-06-08 Robofish 1 (1/0) 2008-01-06 SchuminWeb 1 (1/0) 2009-07-18 63.196.5.128 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2003-03-15 Frecklefoot 1 (0/1) 2003-07-16 Bluppfisk 1 (0/1) 2004-04-18 Dcljr 1 (0/1) 2004-08-13 Morven 1 (0/1) 2004-09-19 Sietse Snel 1 (0/1) 2004-11-11 Beland 1 (0/1) 2005-02-16 Jebba 1 (0/1) 2005-07-25 203.59.103.102 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-12-07 192.234.223.100 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-08-09 JHunterJ 1 (1/0) 2006-09-19 Dfrg.msc 1 (0/1) 2007-03-06 Stefanomione 1 (0/1) 2007-06-22 JPG-GR 1 (1/0) 2007-10-17 88.12.236.254 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-05-02 Kbdankbot (bot) 1 (1/0) 2009-02-13 ![]() |
The result was No consensus. Strictly by counting noses, this would be a straight keep, but some of the "keep" !votes were given somewhat less weight. NAC—S Marshall Talk/Cont 08:28, 13 September 2009 (UTC)
Nominating on behalf of 24.22.141.252, who writes that the article "violates core policies, see WP:V, WP:CITE, WP:NOR - for all we know, this is copyvio or just made up". Skomorokh 11:26, 6 September 2009 (UTC)
Third Sikh Holocaust 1984
27 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 0 Creator: 24.189.173.175 Nominator: Hemlock Martinis
![]() |
The result was Delete. The AFD was closed by YellowMonkey (talk · contribs) who deleted the article at 06:21UTC, September 9, 2009. I am just adding the closing templates and removing subsequent comments. Abecedare (talk) 17:14, 9 September 2009 (UTC)
![]() | If you came here because someone asked you to, or you read a message on another website, please note that this is not a majority vote, but instead a discussion among Wikipedia contributors. Wikipedia has policies and guidelines regarding the encyclopedia's content, and consensus (agreement) is gauged based on the merits of the arguments, not by counting votes.
However, you are invited to participate and your opinion is welcome. Remember to assume good faith on the part of others and to sign your posts on this page by adding ~~~~ at the end. Note: Comments may be tagged as follows. Suspected single-purpose accounts:((subst:spa|username)) , suspected canvassed users: ((subst:canvassed|username)) , accounts blocked for sockpuppetry: ((subst:csm|username)) or ((subst:csp|username)) |
A blatant and clear-cut case of POV pushing. The term "Third Sikh Holocaust" gets only 1,600 hits on Google (the first few of which are YouTube videos) and absolutely zero hits on Google Scholar. Hemlock Martinis (talk) 00:04, 5 September 2009 (UTC)
Guybrush Threepwood
28 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 100 Creator: 217.33.198.207 Nominator: EEMIV
Pictureuploader 32 (32/0) 2008-04-24 62.74.9.121 (anon) 15 (15/0) 2004-12-04 HannuMakinen 14 (9/5) 2006-12-10 LeilaniLad 10 (10/0) 2008-04-16 CountingPine 8 (7/1) 2008-09-06 Kizor 7 (3/4) 2007-04-30 Shadiac 7 (7/0) 2009-06-21 62.74.4.189 (anon) 6 (6/0) 2004-12-12 24.81.74.47 (anon) 5 (5/0) 2007-05-20 82.36.232.41 (anon) 5 (5/0) 2006-05-11 Mullon 5 (5/0) 2008-01-01 24.190.34.219 (anon) 5 (5/0) 2009-07-27 Glaurung 5 (5/0) 2006-09-13 Poulsen 5 (4/1) 2006-04-04 BaronGrackle 5 (5/0) 2008-05-01 202.156.2.138 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2005-03-06 TR Wolf 4 (4/0) 2008-06-30 85.224.55.111 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2006-01-17 YurikBot (bot) 4 (0/4) 2006-03-25 JiFish 4 (4/0) 2006-06-09 83.180.157.0 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2006-06-09 62.74.5.124 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2004-12-05 Supermorff 4 (4/0) 2005-09-23 76.67.136.157 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2009-07-05 Bill 4 (4/0) 2007-11-09 Spearhead 3 (0/3) 2006-09-14 Asbestos 3 (1/2) 2005-02-08 Kuralyov 3 (3/0) 2005-04-04 Lacrimosus 3 (1/2) 2005-05-21 89.240.243.45 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2007-01-27 207.47.140.197 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2007-04-25 76.196.64.65 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2007-05-10 Eloquence 3 (3/0) 2006-11-27 DynSkeet 3 (0/3) 2005-08-12 60.52.74.31 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2008-01-10 12.42.154.40 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-06-17 204.191.140.133 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-08-22 84.251.71.13 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2006-08-27 24.143.150.167 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2006-08-30 62.74.4.147 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2005-01-04 62.190.177.161 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2006-09-20 212.50.170.68 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2006-10-17 62.74.5.100 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2005-04-16 WikiFan04 2 (0/2) 2005-08-15 ThunderPeel2001 2 (0/2) 2005-10-13 EEMIV 2 (2/0) 2009-09-05 RyoBeat 2 (1/1) 2007-09-05 Pairadox 2 (2/0) 2008-01-10 81.215.91.176 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2006-03-27 Matthew Auger 2 (0/2) 2006-04-11 Pele Merengue 2 (2/0) 2007-11-10 Marktreut 2 (2/0) 2007-11-14 91.89.218.226 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-03-28 Mike Rosoft 2 (2/0) 2005-03-21 MoogleDan 2 (2/0) 2007-01-17 92.4.21.46 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2009-08-03 Ketiltrout 2 (0/2) 2007-05-17 The Prince of Darkness 2 (2/0) 2007-09-07 Benzado 1 (0/1) 2006-07-16 137.22.96.87 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-05-01 HHornblower 1 (0/1) 2006-07-28 130.164.66.83 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-05-13 24.92.142.136 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-07-31 Husond 1 (1/0) 2006-08-06 217.33.198.207 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2003-08-14 Lightbot 1 (1/0) 2008-07-06 Pseudomonas 1 (0/1) 2008-07-25 Bryan Derksen 1 (1/0) 2006-08-14 Cheesegoduk 1 (0/1) 2004-12-11 76.191.215.208 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-09-05 82.8.37.43 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-08-29 129.22.41.168 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-09-17 Joshbrez 1 (1/0) 2004-12-23 A More Perfect Onion 1 (1/0) 2008-10-16 129.2.201.50 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-09-08 68.48.28.191 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-01-01 Bladez 1 (1/0) 2008-11-02 24.63.75.39 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-09-10 David Igra 1 (0/1) 2008-12-06 AntiVandalBot 1 (0/1) 2006-09-11 64.251.53.2 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-01-13 24.199.50.187 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-02-05 Telso 1 (0/1) 2005-01-30 Kbdank71 1 (1/0) 2009-04-06 Pushit 1 (1/0) 2006-09-27 RJFJR 1 (0/1) 2005-02-03 84.175.171.247 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-04-16 64.203.8.73 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-10-09 62.74.5.32 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-02-08 76.181.71.186 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-06-02 209.152.59.48 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-10-13 Bite 1 (1/0) 2009-06-09 203.125.109.131 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-04-04 Fish and karate 1 (1/0) 2009-06-16 82.36.133.112 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-10-24 Eternal Pink 1 (1/0) 2009-06-26 194.192.181.248 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2006-11-16 Wereon 1 (0/1) 2005-04-25 Heyheysg 1 (1/0) 2009-06-28 62.74.9.133 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2005-05-18 ![]() |
The result was keep. Cirt (talk) 15:14, 12 September 2009 (UTC)
No assertion of notability. Insignificant references to reliable sources. Is essentially a regurgitation of plot summary covered in games' individual articles. --EEMIV (talk) 21:46, 5 September 2009 (UTC)
Also see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Herman Toothrot, which includes Stan (Monkey Island). Not very good for the nominator to fail to mention the related nominations. Fences&Windows 15:02, 6 September 2009 (UTC)
Dorian Tyrell, Niko (The Mask)
29 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 0 Creator: 217.33.198.207 Nominator: EEMIV
![]() |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dorian Tyrell, Niko (The Mask)
Cathy Worthley
30 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 19 Creator: Cathyworthley Nominator: JaGa
Cameron Scott 11 (11/0) 2009-09-04 Cathyworthley 4 (4/0) 2008-06-28 Milowent 3 (3/0) 2009-09-08 SmackBot (bot) 2 (0/2) 2009-09-02 Pohick2 2 (1/1) 2009-09-04 W guice 2 (1/1) 2008-07-04 Alan Liefting 1 (1/0) 2008-07-04 Richhoncho 1 (0/1) 2008-07-12 70.16.65.27 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-02-23 Camw 1 (0/1) 2009-03-08 Fabrictramp 1 (0/1) 2009-06-02 Benjiboi 1 (1/0) 2009-09-02 Gwen Gale 1 (1/0) 2008-07-04 Lifebaka 1 (1/0) 2008-07-07 Addbot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2009-02-18 67.197.144.104 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-03-08 Synergy 1 (0/1) 2009-04-20 JaGa 1 (1/0) 2009-08-26 ChildofMidnight 1 (1/0) 2009-09-04 ![]() |
The result was delete. A lively debate, but the deletes have the better of it in terms of numbers and sources freely available. I do see this as being a reasonably close call, and those pay site sources could make a difference. I'd be happy to userfy or restore if that is the case. Xymmax So let it be written So let it be done 15:05, 10 September 2009 (UTC)
Fails notability per shallow depth of coverage - see WP:BIO. JaGatalk 22:20, 26 August 2009 (UTC)
Gay Wired - Jul 3, 2008 By Jacob Anderson-Minshall | Article Date: 7/03/2008 12:00 AM. "For the first 20 years of her professional music career, Cathy Worthley was known as Scottish..." and "Transgender Folk Singer Cathy Worthley To Perform at Transgender…" New England Blade - Jun 4, 2008 "Cathy Worthley doesn’t talk much about her self-exile, that period in her life when she disappeared in order to complete her transition..." although I'm having trouble accessing them online. ChildofMidnight (talk) 06:30, 27 August 2009 (UTC)
1) Has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent from the musician or ensemble itself and reliable - two articles - one of which is about them being a transexual.
2) Has had a charted single or album on any national music chart - no.
3) Has had a record certified gold or higher in at least one country - no.
4) Has received non-trivial coverage in a reliable source of an international concert tour, or a national concert tour in at least one sovereign country. - no.
5) Has released two or more albums on a major label or one of the more important indie labels (i.e., an independent label with a history of more than a few years and a roster of performers, many of which are notable). - no.
6) Is an ensemble which contains two or more independently notable musicians, or is a musician who has been a member of two or more independently notable ensembles. - No.
7) Has become the most prominent representative of a notable style or of the local scene of a city; note that the subject must still meet all ordinary Wikipedia standards, including verifiability. - no.
8) Has won or been nominated for a major music award, such as a Grammy, Juno, Mercury, Choice or Grammis award. - no
9) Has won or placed in a major music competition. - no.
10) Has performed music for a work of media that is notable, e.g. a theme for a network television show, performance in a television show or notable film, inclusion on a notable compilation album, etc. (But if this is the only claim, it is probably more appropriate to have a mention in the main article and redirect to that article.) - no.
11) Has been placed in rotation nationally by any major radio network. - no.
12) Has been the subject of a half hour or longer broadcast across a national radio or TV network. - no
So how are any of those keep votes based on the article or the sources? She's a pub singer - nothing wrong with that, I've been a pub singer but it's a trivial thing and not the basis of an article. --Cameron Scott (talk) 21:58, 4 September 2009 (UTC)
List of zombie novels
31 of 31 |
Google
|
Editor Count: 57 Creator: Calendar Nominator: Who then was a gentleman?
Calendar 116 (101/15) 2009-05-27 158.70.145.99 (anon) 43 (43/0) 2008-08-20 203.208.101.112 (anon) 20 (20/0) 2009-09-01 Ikip 13 (13/0) 2009-09-07 Verbal 13 (13/0) 2009-09-07 Zombie Hunter Smurf 9 (9/0) 2009-09-07 DreamGuy 6 (6/0) 2009-09-01 Boy103 6 (6/0) 2009-08-15 76.208.18.107 (anon) 4 (4/0) 2008-11-05 Zedzer 3 (3/0) 2009-07-30 67.140.106.57 (anon) 3 (3/0) 2008-12-11 CoscomEntertainment 3 (3/0) 2009-07-23 Zombieaficionado 3 (2/1) 2009-09-02 McGeddon 2 (2/0) 2008-12-24 122.107.113.111 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-12-22 63.237.114.10 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2009-02-01 70.106.83.248 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2009-02-26 ONEder Boy 2 (0/2) 2009-04-12 Latmrfc 2 (2/0) 2009-06-11 71.217.127.181 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2008-09-14 92.0.198.247 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2009-02-09 76.16.177.97 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2009-03-18 198.236.44.125 (anon) 2 (2/0) 2009-04-27 Spider68 2 (2/0) 2009-08-02 Who then was a gentleman? 2 (2/0) 2009-09-06 Troy 07 1 (0/1) 2008-08-20 Brougham96 1 (0/1) 2008-08-24 Rockstaraddict 1 (1/0) 2008-09-23 222.127.223.75 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-11-10 71.161.250.13 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-12-02 Hammittsays 1 (0/1) 2008-12-05 Pegship 1 (0/1) 2009-02-07 204.120.146.13 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-02-27 Hsw1979 1 (1/0) 2009-03-18 212.3.244.232 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-03-18 207.161.21.172 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-03-25 70.126.219.62 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-04-24 Seantrinityohara 1 (1/0) 2009-08-04 75.7.5.217 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-08-24 Nessyrenay 1 (1/0) 2009-09-01 Tobias Bergemann 1 (0/1) 2009-09-04 Kuralyov 1 (0/1) 2009-09-09 89.243.253.132 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-08-24 LilHelpa 1 (0/1) 2008-11-01 Discospinster 1 (0/1) 2008-11-10 Zolstijers 1 (1/0) 2008-11-11 129.137.155.154 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2008-12-05 67.170.35.55 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-01-01 74.201.138.98 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-02-02 Ogress 1 (1/0) 2009-02-26 221.122.55.10 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-03-15 WereSpielChequers 1 (0/1) 2009-03-24 Jgodoy 1 (1/0) 2009-04-09 SmackBot (bot) 1 (0/1) 2009-04-13 24.239.183.100 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-06-18 71.186.0.121 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-08-20 75.158.198.111 (anon) 1 (1/0) 2009-09-04 ![]() |
The result was keep. The article is going in the right direction at the moment. Keep it this way. Tone 10:40, 13 September 2009 (UTC)
Pretty much an unsourced list of non-notable books and authors. This would be similar to creating List of albums and listing all of the bands which fail WP:BAND. Who then was a gentleman? (talk) 05:13, 6 September 2009 (UTC)