The following discussion is an archived debate of the case of suspected sockpuppetry. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this page. All edits should go to the talk page of this case. If you are seeing this page as a result of an attempt to open a new case of sockpuppetry of the same user, read this for detailed instructions.

User:Azukimonaka[edit]

Suspected sockpuppeteer

Azukimonaka (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · page moves · block user · block log)

Suspected sockpuppets

Various IP editors from Japan's ODN network.

Report submission by Thatcher 17:44, 27 January 2008 (UTC)[reply]

I am filing this report for Appletrees (talk · contribs), who seems to need some help with the process. There are a number of Japanese and Korean editors edit-warring over a number of articles. At least one editor, and possibly two, have taken an interest in Appletrees specifically.

The checkuser findings are given above. See also User_talk:Thatcher#KoreanShoriSenyou_case. For example, on 25 January there were 4 reverts of Imperial House of Japan, two by an IP editor and two by Amazonfire. The same IP editor also reverted Appletrees at Timeline of Japan-South Korea relations and made a comment at Manga, which Appletreees had edited. It is Likely that the IP editor is the same as Orchis29, Azukimonaka and KoreanShoriSenyou. The connection between Amazonfire is more difficult to pin down. Either there are two people who have independently decided to target Appletrees, or there is one person who uses two different methods to connect to the internet and has so far managed to avoid a technical slip (Amazonfire has <100 edits to date). The editor who is behind the Azukimonaka account quite frequently edits while logged out and is POV pusher with a history of uncivil edit summaries. Details in the checkuser reports and I will ask Appletrees to make a comment here.

The evidence of a connection between the named accounts is strong; many IP edits that have a strong anti-Korean POV are likely made by the same person. The connection between Amazonfire and the others is more tenuous and the contribution history should be looked at. Administrative action of some kind is required here, some combination of blocking, warning, and semi-protection for the affected articles.

Evidence

One example, others at the checkuser cases.

Imperial House of Japan (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views)

Possible 3RR violation with ip

1st revert 16:59, 25 January 2008 by 61.209.160.250
2nd revert 21:16, 25 January 2008 by 61.209.160.250
3rd revet 23:20, 25 January 2008 by Amazonfire
4th revert 06:32, 26 January 2008 by Amazonfire

Timeline of Japan-South Korea relations (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views)

This article is created by User:Azukimonaka at 12 October 2007 The dispute between me and Japanese users is inclusion of personal opinion (Japan gave a relief to South Korea) This comment is not mentioned on the citation (it is just a statics) but the Japanese users insist on putting it to the article.

It was originally added by 61.209.165.189 at 07:31, 26 October 2007

1st revert 21:21, 25 January 2008 by 61.209.160.250
2nd revert 23:05, 25 January 2008 by Amazonfire
3rd revert 06:33, 26 January 2008 by Amazonfire

I looked through their whole contribution history and not surprisingly they didn't generally appear same day except a few and their edits are never overlapped. The two violet boxes show the closet time ranges. So if checkusers sees it, they likely can confirm whether Azukimonaka and KoreanShoriSenyou are the same person or not.--Appletrees (talk) 04:29, 30 January 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Relevant pas RFCU and SSP files by other editors

Wikipedia:Requests for checkuser/Case/Kamosuke

User_talk:Akhilleus/archive7#Wikipedia:Suspected_sock_puppets.2FVml132f

Wikipedia:Requests_for_checkuser/Case/DDRG

Wikipedia:Requests_for_checkuser/Case/Ikedanobuo

Wikipedia:Suspected sock puppets/Vml132f

Wikipedia:Requests for checkuser/Case/Vml132f

Wikipedia:Requests_for_checkuser/Case/DDRG

Wikipedia:Requests for checkuser/Case/Mackan

was being writtten
Kamosuke = Azukimonaka = KorenaShoriSenyou = Orchis29 = ShinjukuXYZ = NekoNekoTeacher = Necmate = 43.244.133.167 I believe these people are the same editor per the following reasons. If you see it, you will notice the users' interests are all similar and same pattern of writing such as using passive sentences rather than active sentences such as concealed or denied. They like using "insistence" and "ground" or "groundless" rather claim, assertion or than citation, source, or evidence, etc. I'm not good at writing in English but they all make the same errors in tense such as "was being hated by" etc. The below are distinctive examples for the claim that they're all the same person. 2008-01-06T14:06:43 Grave of the Fireflies‎ (Because Japan behaves like the war victim as for "日 전쟁 피해자 묘사 '반딧불의 묘' 올해 개봉 취소" A, South Korea is being written that screening was stopped.) by Orchis29 2007-12-29T22:22:26 Kaidan The printer was being instructed also by Christianities. by Orchis29 2007-12-15T13:55:59 Japan "Sumo" is not being written, "Japanese wrestling" by KoreanShoriSenyou 2007-10-02T08:31:05 Chongryon‎ (The Japanese was often murdered by the riot by Confederation of Koreans Living in Japan. As a result, Confederation of Koreans Living in Japan is being hated by Japan now.) by KoreanShoriSenyou 2007-10-02T08:08:52 2006 North Korean nuclear test‎ (Japan executes the economic sanction to North Korea, and is being continued now due to this event.) by KoreanShoriSenyou 2007-10-04T10:28:43 Neo Gomanism Manifesto Special - On War‎ (The content that criticizes China to this book is not being written. Please write the content of the book in Talkpage because it is asking. (Perhaps, you are describing it not well-grounded. )) by KoreanShoriSenyou 2007-11-13T09:57:00 Eugenics Showa Japan is a section that Flying-Tyger personally added on October 20, 2007 is being Wikipedia talk:Requests for mediation/Eugenics in Showa Japan by Azukimonaka 2007-09-20T10:02:59 Juicy girl‎ (Japan is not being written in the source.) by Azukimonaka 2007-07-07T05:09:21 Kombu‎ (→Reference - rv: It is not being written Chinese ingredients.) by Azukimonaka 2007-06-23T22:40:43 Blade of the Phantom Master‎ (→External links - This comic is not a grammar of Manhwa. This comic is being written by the grammar of Manga.) by Azukimonaka As for Kamosuke, he and HaradaSanosuke are the banned socks on August 2006 and are‎ Softbank odn ISP users = 211.131.78.52 [1]. Their (actually one person) writing style remarkably resemble that of Azukimonaka, KoreanShoriSenyou, Orchis29. I haven't looked through Kamasuke's contribution history, but he also made the same errors in writing past tense. ("was being written by someone") Kamosuke created his account at 2005-11-19T08:01:02.[2] According to the remain block log, He had been a long-time abusive troll and I strongly believe he has transformed as new edior with countless sock puppetry. Wikipedia:Requests for checkuser/Case/Kamosuke Kamosuke (talk · contribs)'s edit summaries * [ 2006-07-06T16:43:54‎] Japan‎ (→Classical era - Baekje is still being discussed. see Talk) 2006-06-30T05:35:20‎ Japan‎ (→Classical era - Baekje is being discussed. And, it doesn't agree. This topic is not urgent. Please do Talk.) 2006-06-24T02:21:15‎ Japan-Korea relations‎ (Appleby. Please stop the data of sales and the audience rating being deleted. Moreover, please stop deleting the activity of the Japanese culture.) 2006-06-19T11:05:55‎ Japan‎ (→Pre-history - http://cache.britannica.com/eb/article-8481 Shinto - Korea is not being written.) 2006-06-18T01:46:49‎ Japan‎ (rv: Tortfeasor. Reason - Korean POV. He changed China to Korea. The explanation of the source is being written in Talk.) 2006-06-01T09:21:47‎ Japan‎ (Dogcow, Yes. In South Korea, there is an unique culture. (EX hungle)　However, the culture is not being imported by Japan.) 2006-05-01T01:06:31‎ Kofun period‎ (To Korean. Korean doesn't stop the history record(Samguk Sagi Book of Sui Book of Song) being deleted. Koreans never write the deletion reason.Korean should stop the history revisim) 2006-04-15T14:02:00‎ Yamato period‎ (The same content is being repeatedly written. Therefore, the overlapping part is united to Torai-jin (渡来人).　) 2006-02-09T04:16:02‎ Korea‎ (→Joseon - Rejection: citations　is not being offered. There is no history in talk.) 2006-02-07T10:16:47‎ Responses of Germany and Japan to World War II crimes‎ (→Korea - International Military Tribunal for the Far East Korean's war crime person's (B&C class war crime person) introduction is being prepared. Please stand by) 2005-11-28T07:14:55‎ Korea‎ (→Japanese occupation - Please stop the article being quietly replaced. The discussion is welcomed.) 43.244.133.167 (talk⁺ · tag · contribs · filter log · WHOIS · RBLs · proxy check · block user · block log · cross-wiki contribs · CheckUser (log)) This apparent sock ip doesn't seem to be a dynamic address. I think this should be blocked infinitely as well. 2008-01-09T08:42:10 Japanese cruiser Tsushima‎ (It shows a Korean peninsula of the name of a place. If the country is shown, it will be written South Korea.) 2007-10-04T09:30:37 Kyōgaku no Gaijin Hanzai Ura File - Gaijin Hanzai Hakusho 2007‎ (rv Please write Anti-Chinese sentiment in Japan being written in this book in Talkpage.) 2007-04-09T08:37:28 Yakiniku‎ (rv: http://www.japan-guide.com/e/e2036.htm <- This is information not being written in this source. "What goes under the name yakiniku in Japan will most of ...") ShinjukuXYZ (talk⁺ · tag · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log · CA · CheckUser(log) · investigate · cuwiki) NekoNekoTeacher (talk⁺ · tag · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log · CA · CheckUser(log) · investigate · cuwiki) Although ShinjukuXYZ was proven as a sock of NekoNekoTeacher, they were not infinitely blocked. They seem abusively used the accounts though. I think this account should be infinitely blocked along with another sock accounts. 2007-03-18T09:41:17 Yakiniku‎ (As for phonmonky Best, the source is wrong. And, the erroneous information is being written. Please think well again.) 2007-02-21T06:29:59 Emperor of Japan‎ (→History - The source is being written Korean peninsula.) 2007-02-21T06:13:10 Soga clan‎ (The Soga clan is an aristocrat with the emperor leaving home body. Please look at the genealogy of the Soga clan being written in the source.) 2007-02-21T06:05:12 Kofun period‎ (rv:Tressco Version is a version that the Socks user in Korean pressed. A lot of problems of this version are being written in Talkpage. Please edit it after answering all.) 2007-01-01T02:44:11 Emperor Ingyō‎ ("According to contemporary historians....," This episode is not being written in NihonShoki and Kojiki. Moreover, there is no historian who does this insistence.) 2006-12-07T10:34:37 Toyotomi Hideyoshi‎ (rv: The topic is being discussed. Please look at TalkPage.) Necmate (talk⁺ · tag · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log · CA · CheckUser(log) · investigate · cuwiki) 2007-03-22T08:27:07 Mike Honda‎ (→Comfort women - [3] "50,000 to 300,000" is not being written in this source.) 2007-03-09T08:52:13 Comfort women‎ (Is this being written in the source? "the majority of the women were recruited by force or deception.")

--Appletrees (talk) 01:26, 1 February 2008 (UTC)[reply]

same writing style
the erroneous information They write poor wording in English and the literary word, erroneous is not commonly used and is likely for non-English speakers to see it in advanced test preparation books like GRE, GMAT. Although the ISP is not ODN (SoftBank Telecom) but OCN (NTT telecom), these user are all same user. 2007-03-18T09:41:17 Yakiniku‎ (As for phonmonky Best, the source is wrong. And, the erroneous information is being written. Please think well again.) by ShinjukuXYZ (talk · contribs) 2008-01-29T05:57:29 He often writes the erroneous information. He calls all users who corrected his mistake Socks though we correct his mistake. We will be able to participate in the article without using IP if you cooperate so that a Japanese user may contribute to the article on Japan. To our regret, all users who pointed out the mistake of Appletree are indicted as Socks. by 124.87.134.96 (talk · contribs)= OCN, NTT user delete is returned 2006-11-02T13:15:03 Korea‎ (→History - The source of Carter Eckerd whom Room218 deleted is returned. And, the source (http://www.kimsoft.com/2002/jp-rape.htm) that Room218 added is deleted.) by NekoNekoTeacher (talk · contribs) 2007-10-04T10:25:41 7-Eleven‎ (Deleted information is returned.) by 211.3.113.247 (talk · contribs) 2008-01-24T10:55:24 Manga‎ (Destruction by the Korean was restored. [4]]) by Orchis29 (talk · contribs) 2008-01-13T23:59:24 National Treasures of South Korea‎ (The source that the South Korean user concealed is returned.) by Orchis29 (talk · contribs) Probaganda 2006-10-17T06:09:49 Japanese war crimes‎ (→Later investigations - The part without the source is deleted. Perhaps, South Korean's Probaganda) by NekoNekoTeacher (talk · contribs) 2007-07-24T19:08:49 The source is Probagandasait of Korea. (The name of the Sea of Japan is denied there. )Please quote it from Fenollosa's book. by 219.66.44.159 (talk · contribs) 2007-10-05T16:40:41 It is anti-Japanese Probaganda by Chinese Communist Party to delete law grounds, and to insist on Holocaust of Asia. by 211.3.113.247 (talk · contribs) Insistence [2007-02-22T18:07:13] Soga clan‎ (Please do not conceal Soga clan's family pedigree to insist on the lie of Korea) 2008-01-13T23:56:23 Kofun period‎ (The insistence without grounds by the Korean user is deleted. Please come to the discussion page.) by Orchis29 (talk · contribs) 2008-01-12T04:02:09 Nihon Shoki‎ (The Japanese has a bias in the history. The user who doesn't admit my opinion is Sockpuppet. The Korean user's insistence is not tenable at all.) by 61.116.114.212 (talk · contribs) Loved 2007-10-04T09:48:32 Japanese war crimes‎ (Please present the legal basis. Whether you keep speaking ill of Japan because you love Chinese Communist Party?) by 43.244.133.167 (talk · contribs) 2008-01-06T14:15:02 Japanese handicrafts‎ (Because you are South Korean, South Korea is loved. However, the source of this culture is not Korea but China.) by Orchis29 (talk · contribs) Steal [2008-01-22T09:35:19] Dekopon‎ (RV Dkopon is fruits to which the kind is improved in Kumamoto in Japan. Korean User must not steal the culture of Japan.) by 124.87.134.96 (talk · contribs) 2008-01-23T14:09:39 Pyrus pyrifolia‎ (The Korean generally uses Hangul. http://news.google.co.jp/news?ned=kr&btn=Go　Why does Korean User keep stealing a Chinese culture?) by 219.66.44.214 (talk · contribs) Mr. or To Korean 2007-09-19T15:10:59 Eugenics in Showa Japan‎ (The source without a large amount of grounds that Fly put is divided. Mr. Fly. Please present the source.) by Azukimonaka (talk · contribs) 2007-09-04T12:28:55 Imperial Regalia of Japan‎ ("One or more of these may not be the originals. " This is a personal imagination of the Mr fly.) by Azukimonaka (talk · contribs) 2008-01-22T09:32:13 Manhwa‎ (Mr Korean. Please do a logical explanation. What is the etymology of Manhwa?) 124.87.134.96 (talk · contribs) 2008-01-22T09:43:56 Timeline of Japan-South Korea relations‎ ("To rescue the South Korea economy, Japan supported it" Mr ]Korean Why is it POV?) 124.87.134.96 (talk · contribs) [2008-01-08T17:42:44] Nihon Shoki‎ (To two Korean. Please write your insistences in Talkpage. Insisting Bais on an unpleasant history description for Korean people is not logical.) by 219.66.41.150 (talk · contribs) 2008-01-22T09:52:48 Pyrus pyrifolia‎ (To Korean people. It is Chinese that is written in the label. (幸福康寧) Please think logically.) by 124.87.134.96 (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · page moves · block user · block log) by 124.87.134.96 (talk · contribs) 2008-01-22T09:15:17 Manhwa‎ (To the Korean user. Manhwa is Term that translated Japanese Manga into a Korean language.)} by 124.87.134.96 (talk · contribs) Manhwa 2007-12-15T04:22:33 The etymology of Manhwa is Manga. It is not Comic.by Azukimonaka (talk · contribs) 2007-09-21T12:16:48 Bucheon International Manga festival by Azukimonaka (talk · contribs) 2008-01-22T09:32:13 Manhwa‎ (Mr Korean. Please do a logical explanation. What is the etymology of Manhwa?) by 219.66.44.214 (talk · contribs) Shame, education 2007-10-04T09:43:57 Kyōgaku no Gaijin Hanzai Ura File - Gaijin Hanzai Hakusho 2007‎ (This book is culture and literature?. Be ashamed of the low degree of your education. And, please write the content of this book in Talkpage.) by 43.244.133.167 (talk · contribs) 2008-01-23T14:04:06 Manhwa‎ (To uneducated Korean User. Manga is Japanese that uses the Chinese character. Please explain the origin of Term of Manhwa.) by 219.66.44.214 (talk · contribs)

--Appletrees (talk) 15:13, 1 February 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Comments

Appletrees asked me to comment here, and I'll state it bluntly: blocks and protection all round, either we have socks of a disruptive and poisonously biased user who is a complete waste of space, or multiple users who fall into that category. However, that's my gut feeling from a quick check, rather than the more exhaustive checking and investigating process that will probably be required. I'm not on as much these days, and can't commit myself to more in-depth analysis right now. In past dealings with the user I recall I was frequently reverting and blocking. Deiz talk 14:57, 31 January 2008 (UTC)[reply]

According to your investigation, Neither Orchis29 nor Amazonfire appear. Who does want to indict it by you? Who do you want to accuse? --KoreanShoriSenyou (talk) 10:02, 1 February 2008 (UTC)[reply]

I relocate your comment because you left it in the wrong place. I don't need to paste the same contents of the RFCU file on you. You can visit the page and find about how many times your possible sockpuppt activities are mentioned. As you see this file is reported by Thactcher, the trusted checkuser and admin. Not only abovementioned users, there will be much more than that. In addition, of course, in the "was being written box", you and orchies29 mentioned. As for Amazonfire, I'm cleaning up my another report a bit, so you wouldn't miss to see it soon.--Appletrees (talk) 10:12, 1 February 2008 (UTC)[reply]

OK. By the way, You insist, 25 users are "Koreansyorisenyo's account".[5] However, does it have grounds?. For instance, Endroit rejected your opinion by the name of the Sea of Japan. (You are requesting that the Sea of Japan is changed to a local name of Korea "East Sea". ) Amazonfire conflicts with you by the doubt of the author of So Far from the Bamboo Grove. You are indiscriminately indicting the user who opposes your opinion. Do you have the preparation for apologizing to them? --KoreanShoriSenyou (talk) 10:40, 1 February 2008 (UTC)[reply]

KoreanShoriSenyou or Exclusive use for disposal of Chosenjin, I have no plan to let you you indulging your insistence. Endroit hasn't apologized to me for his accusation yet and the suspected people have been always on RFCU or SSP because of their suspicious and disruptive POV pushing. I haven't tagged "sock accusation" template on you and the others for their reputation, so I can hear your appreciation for that. However, you should apologize for your deception and mockery with your account name to all Korean editors. --Appletrees (talk) 10:54, 1 February 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Conclusions: I am blocking 43.244.133.167 for a month and Orchis29, Azukimonaka and KoreanShoriSenyou indef each, with KoreanShoriSenyou the master account. — Rlevse • Talk • 22:24, 2 February 2008 (UTC)...IP already blocked 3 months by other admin. — Rlevse • Talk • 22:28, 2 February 2008 (UTC)[reply]