I believe the references show that the subject meets the following criteria. The references has the person as the main subject and not just a passing mention as part of the group.
1. Has been the subject of multiple, non-trivial, published works appearing in sources that are reliable, not self-published, and are independent of the musician or ensemble itself.
A big difference from the other version is a reliance on published sources like news reports and magazines rather than Youtube videos. Firezzasd (talk) 18:10, 1 June 2024 (UTC)[reply]
Don't see how "reliance on published sources like news reports and magazines" is of any differences to the pointers raised by Explicit in the previous AfD, pretty close in my opinion. —Paper9oll(🔔 • 📝)18:41, 1 June 2024 (UTC)[reply]
The main difference is that discussion is from June 2021. There's more reporting on the subject in the last three years, as evident in the references. I think if the concern is independent notability, that's no longer an issue as compared to back then. Firezzasd (talk) 18:59, 1 June 2024 (UTC)[reply]
More as in? Other than 1 hosting news releases (pretty much routine), health issues (ref bombing), 1 cover magazine featured, endorsements for 1 bag brand (ref bombing) and shoe brand (ref bombing). And minus here and there compared to the deleted article due to no reliable sources available. So where exactly does WP:SINGER and WP:BANDMEMBER criteria is fulfiled? —Paper9oll(🔔 • 📝)07:15, 2 June 2024 (UTC)[reply]
Strong Keep: I think the nominator is more likely arguing that Yeh Shu-hua does not demonstrate sufficient individual notability to have a standalone article and should be redirected, rather than filing for a deletion. Then I guess it would be more helpful if the nominator would elaborate on their rationale for considering the other four out of five members to have individual notability (Soojin debuted solo so I am not counting her), while singling out Yeh as lacking it. As a Taiwanese member whose career has been based in Korea, I have looked into sources covering her in both Chinese and Korean. I can't read Korean, so I could only run sources with a translator and it seems like there are quite a lot sources that cover Shu-hua personally, most notably is her solo work as the host of WORKDOL (see My Daily [ko][1] and Nate News[2], and I later also found coverage in Chinese sources, like Elle[3] and ETToday [zh][4]) and appearances in variety shows. (See Segye Ilbo[5], Global Economy Newspaper [ko][6], Zum [ko][7], etc.) I do read Chinese though, and found a lot more sources with SIGCOV about her career, personal life and controversies. (See Elle[8], GQ Taiwan[9], SET News[10], Nownews[11], United Daily News[12], Jusky [zh][13], Storm Media [zh][14], TVBS News[15] etc.) There are also media coverage on some of her solo works in Taiwan, such as participating in the Taiwanese game show Mr. Player [zh] (see Liberty Times[16] and China Times[17]), a recent travel program with Bolin Chen, (see Oriental Daily News[18]), or performing at Golden Wave At Taiwan. (See Mirror Media[19] and ETToday[20]) Considering the sources already presented in the article and provided by Cunard in the previous AFD, as well as the additional ones I have listed out, I think it is more than enough to show that the subject person has well passed GNG. The SIGCOV on the subject person's solo works are also sufficient to demonstrate the individual notability. So it is a quite obvious pass of both GNG and BANDMEMBER in my opinion. —Prince of Erebor（The Book of Mazarbul）10:37, 2 June 2024 (UTC)[reply]
Read through the majority of the linked news articles above, still couldn't find where is the individual notability as a SINGER and BANDMEMBER.
Routine coverage and/or summary of her appearance in Workdol's episode
Another routine coverage and/or summary of her appearance in Workdol's episode
Digest/rundown/roundup's news article of her
Another routine coverage and/or summary of her appearance in Workdol's episode
Gossip coverage on her attitude on Civilization Express
Just a photo coverage of her aheading to Music Bank
Routine coverage and/or summary of her appearance on Knowing Bros, as part of promotion with (G)I-dle
Another digest/rundown/roundup's news article of her
Yet another digest/rundown/roundup's news article of her
An article about her debut with (G)I-dle, pretty much yet another digest/rundown/roundup's news article of her
Yet another digest/rundown/roundup's news article of her
Yet another digest/rundown/roundup's news article of her
Coverage of her Instagram post, yet another digest/rundown/roundup's news article
Coverage of her Instagram post, basically a gossip coverage
Routine coverage and/or summary of her appearance in Mr. Player's episode
Same as #16, basically a copy-paste plus-minus coverage
Routine coverage of her returning to work after illness
Routine coverage on Golden Wave at Taiwan concert, she is mentioned in PASSINGMENTION as (G)I-dle is performing there
Routine coverage on her special MC/host apperance on Golden Wave at Taiwan concert (the same event as #19)
In relation to "[the] rationale for considering the other four out of five members to have individual notability", I'm not sure why I'm even answering this question when a quick scan through each (Cho Mi-yeon, Minnie, Jeon So-yeon, Song Yuqi) already given the obvious answer of meeting GNG and/or BLP and/or SINGER and/or BANDMEMBER criteria. —Paper9oll(🔔 • 📝)12:58, 2 June 2024 (UTC)[reply]
@Paper9oll: Hi Paper9oll! Hmm... I believe it is necessary to clarify your expectations for individual notability in order to reach a consensus here. I am not particularly familiar with (G)I-dle, as far as I know, the key difference between Yeh and the other members is that she did not have any individual musical releases. (If I remember correctly Yuqi had her article before releasing her first solo single though) However, I don't think debuting solo is a crucial criterion for determining individual notability, and it is not explicitly stated in BANDMEMBER either. (Ryujin and Lia come to mind as a counterexample.) Aside from this, I do not think the media coverage of Minnie and Yuqi should differ significantly from that of Yeh. I also found it difficult to agree with about half of the summaries you provided. For instance, I cited sources mentioning Yeh hosting Workdol, participating in variety programs, and co-hosting an upcoming travel program with Chen Bolin (the latter was mistakenly labeled as covering her returning from illness). I was intending to emphasize Yeh's solo activities, which I see as demonstrating her individuality, rather than the overall notability. I am also slightly puzzled by how these can be considered routine coverage, or else an actor's entire filmography can be viewed as just their "another day of work" as well. Another key point of disagreement is the categorization of the Chinese sources covering her biography as news digests. SIGCOV never emphasizes that the subject person has to be a unique or major topic of the source, but rather require the source to address the subject person directly and in detail only. These few sources are entirely about Yeh's biography, even the title singled her out instead of referring her as a group. I guess there isn't really room of argument that those sources are direct and detailed addresses. I think this level of SIGCOV on Yeh's early life, career, and personal life far exceeds the requirements of GNG. While I may concede that Yeh's lack of a solo debut could be seen as not meeting BANDMEMBER for individual notability, it is still unconvincing to dismiss the aforementioned sources as run-of-the-mill. I agree to disagree, but respectfully I think the subject person has undoubtedly fulfilled GNG. —Prince of Erebor（The Book of Mazarbul）14:53, 2 June 2024 (UTC)[reply]