The result was no consensus, defaulting to keep. Can't sleep, clown will eat me 20:19, 15 August 2006 (UTC)[reply]
Article covering a wiki about the game World of Warcraft. The first afds resulted in a keep. Imo, it is not notable enough to be included on Wikipedia and fails WP:V and WP:WEB. The notability template has been slapped on the article but the editors have not provided any evidence of significant coverage by any reliable sources since the last afd and have removed the notability template. Forums and blogs appear to be the only linking pages to this site.
To compare: FFXIclopedia, a wiki about the MMORPG Final Fantasy XI has been up for AfD 3 times. Also, FFXIclopedia continues to rise in Alexa rankings, surpassing the official Final Fantasy XI website. WoWWiki remains an underdog to the official World of Warcraft site. The editors of the WoWWiki article still haven't provided any evidence of outside coverage by reliable sources (WP:RS). --Ganiman 18:50, 10 August 2006 (UTC)[reply]
Disregarding the mess above, I think the article should be deleted as well. I have slapped a notability tag on it last week but no reliable sources covering the wiki have been added. Currently the article fails WP:WEB and WP:V. The result of the last afd was keep but no actual evidence of notability was given there either, other than the site having a high alexa ranking. The wiki has received about 22 million page views but wikis with similar amounts of page views have had their article deleted or are being put up for afd at the moment. Peephole 20:11, 10 August 2006 (UTC)[reply]
Comment: we have conflicting precedents here, now that FFXIclopedia was outright deleted. I have summarised the situation for the three MMORPG-related wikis in the table directly below.
Wiki WP article AfD consensus Alexa rank ((NUMBEROFARTICLES)) # users # hits WoWWiki WoWWiki keep 5,318 [1] 14,315 38,151 22,593,490 GuildWiki GuildWiki merge to Guild Wars 6,055 [2] 9,030 11,668 114,958,863 FFXIclopedia FFXIclopedia delete
no consensue
delete33,697 [3] 15,075 104,263 17,825,895 All three wikis are linked to from their respective game websites. — Kaustuv Chaudhuri 01:10, 12 August 2006 (UTC)