The result was delete all -- I suggest deletion review if anyone objects to a particular deletion, or if a consensus is developed to merge these. Luna Santin 23:05, 1 November 2006 (UTC)[reply]
nn junior league hockey player, fails the current WP:BIO guidelines, as this player plays in a junior league, which is not "fully professional". Also possibly violates WP is not a crystal ball. Tony fanta 23:41, 27 October 2006 (UTC)[reply]
I am also nominating the following related pages because they are also junior league hockey players for the Saginaw Spirit that do not meet the criteria of WP:BIO. I looked at their roster and only tagged the ones that have not been drafted by the NHL, (although some of the others may not be notable as well, I will not tag them for this discussion):
Delete all, sadly.Comment I do not know much about OHL players, but one thing I would suggest if you look up other articles for future AfDs that you see if any of these players have participated in an event like the World Junior Ice Hockey Championships, or were first round picks in the NHL Entry Draft. Those would be two such cases where I think a junior player would automatically qualify as notable. In the case of his removing the AfD notices, I am going to assume good faith and believe that is simply the result of his not understanding how the AfD proccess works, or notability criteria.
Also, since this user has put some work into these articles, and since players on major-junior rosters may have short term notability, especially in Canada, would there be an objection to having these articles merged into something like Saginaw Spirit roster? Resolute 06:00, 29 October 2006 (UTC)[reply]