09:1809:18, 18 March 2023diffhist+35
Lionel Messi
UEFA considers it as an official honour and no matter if it doesn't satisfy you or not, even the official European football governing body acknowledges it, you have to include it as it is. Either you can accept it, or you can as mentioned add and end note. If you're simply egoistical to support your own stand then, it's no use talking to you.Tags: RevertedVisual editMobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
10:0210:02, 17 March 2023diffhist+201
Lionel Messi
You are doing that. It is clearly mentioned both in Barcelona page and the Wikipedia page of Messi's achievements that 2005 Spanish supercup is included. Doesn't matter if it doesn't satisfy your personal verdict. If it's counted by official source, Wikipedia should include itTags: UndoRevertedMobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
06:4306:43, 16 March 2023diffhist+201
Lionel Messi
Already mentioned, since the official club considers the 2005 SuperCup among his honours, physical or otherwise proofs don't matter. Personal discretion can be given on personal sources but on a public directory, records should be as given by official organisations, in this case Football club Barcelona.Tags: UndoRevertedMobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
15:2615:26, 15 March 2023diffhist+201
Lionel Messi
The official Barcelona page lists the 2005 SuperCopa de España. Hence it is an official title. I hope you understand that's how it works. The club decides which player has what.Tags: UndoRevertedMobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
13 March 2023
05:1505:15, 13 March 2023diffhist+398
Cristiano Ronaldo
The Official Real Madrid and Manchester United websites count the 2016 UEFA super Cup and 2008 FA community Shield among the honours of Cristiano Ronaldo. As such they should be added in the Wikipedia page.Tags: UndoRevertedMobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
16:3216:32, 12 March 2023diffhist+165
Lionel Messi
Made changes in the honours section. The official Barcelona page considers the 2005 Spanish super Cup among his honours, as such it has to be added. The Wikipedia page on his accomplishments also considers it.Tags: Visual editMobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
15:5015:50, 3 March 2023diffhist+398
Cristiano Ronaldo
Already mentioned, as he was a member in the league and cup competitions, he would get the medal. Same with UEFA super Cup as according to UEFA rules, as long as they played in UEFA champions league between 2015-2018 seasons were able to get winners medal for SuperCup. Whether it be Europa or UCL.Tags: UndoRevertedMobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
12:1812:18, 3 March 2023diffhist+27
Cristiano Ronaldo
He was part of the team in both seasons and winners medal is given to not only squad on match day but everyone who was part of the FA Cup/premier league squad for community shield and UCL for super Cup. As such he was given both medals. Hence 34 career team trophies.Tags: RevertedVisual editMobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
09:5509:55, 2 March 2023diffhist+305
Cristiano Ronaldo
While Ronaldo didn't play in 2008 community shield and 2016 UEFA super Cup, as he was part of the official squads, this he was awarded winner's medals for both. As such he has been recognised to have won 34 trophies instead of 32.Tags: RevertedVisual editMobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit