12:1312:13, 2 January 2019diffhist+100
History of wine
In my previous edit I added a full Quote of scholars Li et al 2018 (somehow the edit summary explanation comment did not show up), as well as added the sources where they are needed. Now adding a direct link to that Peer Reviewed Academic Source.
11:4911:49, 2 January 2019diffhist+1,127
History of wine
Adding new sources to where they belong and restoring suspicious removals/blanking of McGovern's quote at (02:50, 10 February 2018) and subsequent insertion of his own unsourced changes in the edits that followed - from an editor with large amounts of WP:VD warnings on his talk page and talk archives...
06:5406:54, 2 January 2019diffhist+22
History of wine
Refer to the 22 January 2018 version (which restored WP:OR / WP:SYNTH defacement of this page to make a specific nation with 6000bc wine the earliest, against what the academic sources actually stated [grape wine was found at 7000 BC in another nation]) - explicitly wrote "wine" not "wine grapes", Changing it to "wine produced from grapes" as per page, sounds much better, but not "wine grapes", which is still incorrect...
06:1906:19, 2 January 2019diffhist+1,064
History of wine
Undid revision 876394723 by Wikaviani (talk) Where did I ever state otherwise? Restoring the page subject back to "wine" when someone turned the page subject to "wine grapes" (see the difference) is legit. More importantly, why did you gloss over the Fact that So Many Academic Sources that Clearly stated it is exactly about Grape Wine at 7000 BC (and even older) for the Chinese? From Academic & Peer Reviewed Journals in 2018 no less?Tag: Undo
1 January 2019
22:1022:10, 1 January 2019diffhist−7
History of wine
"wine grapes"? This is the wine page, not "wine grape" page. Possible vandalism detected. Restoring to original version of the content.
02:1302:13, 1 January 2019diffhist+471
History of wine
Adding a New Peer Reviewed Journal (ScienceDirect, Elsevier) by professors Li et al (2018) - "Following the definition of the CNCCEF, China has been viewed as “ New New World ” in the world wine map, despite the fact that grape growing and wine making in China date back to between 7000BCE and 9000BCE."
02:0102:01, 1 January 2019diffhist+317
History of wine
New source found, Professors Li and Bardaji, University of Madrid Spain - "Several archaeological discoveries have proofed the activities of grape producing and grape fermentation in China with a span of 8,000 B.C. to 3,000 B.C. historically."
01:3001:30, 1 January 2019diffhist+849
History of wine
Reinserting McGovern et al 2004 which got lost during reversion of Original Research and Synth Violations. Caution is required as it is a Primary Source. And, it was already cited directly by McGovern in his work, initially already on this wikipage, Thus might not be deemed an independent third party source. Thus adding a new Peer Reviewed Journal by Prof Cañete et al 2018 stating: "According to the earliest archaeological evidence, the first grape wine dates back to 7000 BCE in China [6]"
00:5600:56, 1 January 2019diffhist−566
History of wine
No Original Research and No Personal Attacks (Slander), pointing out WP:OR and WP:SYNTH is Legitimate. Stop playing victim when you got caught repeatedly violating Original Research and SYNTH. Stop WP:OR Twisting McGovern's work (he doesn't know if it was mixed or grapes alone) but you WP:SYNTH it in to Castro-Sowinski (2016) as well a Hames (2010) who never cited him for this specific issue, nor ever mentioned the grape wine mixed. No Original Research.Tag: references removed