Table of MuZemike and A Nobody's participation in AfDs[edit]

Discussion MuZemike's stance A Nobody's stance Outcome
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arathi Redirect Keep WHAT A LONG STRANGE ROAD IT'S BEEN
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Campaigns of Pharaoh and Cleopatra Delete[1] Keep delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Childe (World of Darkness) Weak keep Keep no consensus to delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diadem of Maunstraut Nominated Delete delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Enemies in The Legend of Zelda series (2nd nomination) Keep Very strong keep keep
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guardian Units of Nations N/A[2] Keep no consensus/keep
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kamael Merge[3] Keep Merge
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kokoro (Dead or Alive) Redirect Keep Merge or...redirect
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa (Dead or Alive) Redirect[4] Keep Merge
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Chronicles of the Sword characters Transwiki...delete[5] Keep delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Cogs Redirect Keep delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of controversial video games Keep Keep no consensus
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Crusader equipment Delete[6] Keep Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Elite Four members Merge...delete Keep Keep
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Paper Mario series characters split...redirect[7] Keep no consensus
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Pokémon items (2nd nomination) Delete and transwiki Very strong keep Delete[8]
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of units in the Age of Mythology series Keep Keep No consensus
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Logitech Racing Wheels compatibility Keep Strong keep Keep
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mangle Time Strong delete Delete speedy delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mobians Merge...delete[9] Strong keep DELETE
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mortimer Goth Transwiki...merge Keep delete[10]
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Odessa (Wild Arms 2) Delete Keep delete[11]
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raccoon City (2nd nomination) Speedy keep Strong, maybe even speedy keep Keep
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spaceships of Eve Online (2nd nomination) Redirect Speedy keep Delete[12]
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stilwater Delete...Redirect[13] Keep redirect
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Endless Forest Keep...cleanup Keep keep
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tina Armstrong Redirect Keep Keep
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WASD keys (2nd nomination) Closed as non-admin closure Keep Merge[14]

Notes[edit]

  1. ^ A variation of the WP:PERNOM style of argument to avoid.
  2. ^ No argument, just a rather mocking call to prove it.
  3. ^ Stance is consistent with outcome, but no argument (no why we should merge), just a stance.
  4. ^ Antagonistic copy and paste as confirmed in edit summary.
  5. ^ Wikipedia is a colloborative effort. All participants in these discussions really should help each other out with sourcing.
  6. ^ Stance is consistent with outcome, but no explanation of how it is a game guide and why we should not cover such content.
  7. ^ Disappointing assumption of bad faith against Wikipedia:Article Rescue Squadron and a bit overly dramatic exit from discussion. Many members of the group do argue to delete in AfDs and do not simply think all articles are "good" as is, but that they have potential.
  8. ^ Close allowed for "restoration for very selective merger possible".
  9. ^ No reason (why) provided.
  10. ^ Close allowed for a redirect.
  11. ^ Close allowed for a redirect.
  12. ^ Baffling bad close.
  13. ^ It is good to see open-mindedness is these discussions, i.e. a willingness to accept an alternative solution to deletion when offered.
  14. ^ Reasonable close.
More