The result of the discussion was: delete. ♠PMC♠ (talk) 21:12, 2 June 2019 (UTC)
This US state portal was created in 2007 by two Wikipedia editors, one of whom is now banned, and User:Elpiseos has been inactive since 2013. This is a heritage-style portal with subpages, which require maintenance, but it has not been maintained. Inspection shows that the Selected Article, Selected Biography, and Selected Picture were selected in 2007. There have been minor tweaks, such as the addition of approximately 86 (less than 365) daily history files, but the In The News events are all from the previous decade. Some American editors will say that every US state is a broad subject area and should have a portal, but a portal should have a portal maintainer, and unmaintained portals are litter by the side of the information superhighway. Some editors say that the lack of a portal maintainer should be dealt with by normal editing and tagging. The portal has an average of 12 daily pageviews, as opposed to 2483 for the article. I tagged the portal on 15 May. No one has answered.
Perhaps the advocates of portals will try to call portal maintainers from the vasty deep like spirits by Glendower. As Hotspur replies, will one come? Will he ride heroically back from Philadelphia with Caesar Rodney? Will she swim ashore from the vasty deep in Rehoboth Beach? Will he arrive by a more modern means such as F-16 at Dover AFB? Will it arise like a Frankenstein monster from the laboratories of DuPont in Wilmington? Robert McClenon (talk) 20:37, 26 May 2019 (UTC)
The following table provides daily pageview statistics for US states and other subnational units. This includes all of the subnational units that have been nominated for deletion, and some US states that have been included for comparison. All of the states included for comparison are relatively small states.
Title | Portal Page Views | Article Page Views | Ratio | Notes | Percent |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Maine | 10 | 2,999 | 299.9 | 0.33% | |
Brittany | 9 | 1,725 | 191.7 | 0.52% | |
Greenland | 10 | 6,632 | 663.2 | 0.15% | |
Azad Kashmir | 6 | 1,657 | 276.2 | The number used is the median. The mean is 4595 due to a weird spike on 26 Feb. | 0.36% |
Chechnya | 10 | 3,014 | 301.4 | 0.33% | |
Faisalbad | 2 | 442 | 221.0 | 0.45% | |
Silesia | 9 | 896 | 99.6 | 1.00% | |
Kashmir | 15 | 2,349 | 156.6 | Median listed, mean is 6162, weird peak on 27 Feb | 0.64% |
Bavaria | 11 | 2,799 | 254.5 | Not currently nominated. | 0.39% |
Micronesia | 14 | 1,469 | 104.9 | 0.95% | |
French Polynesia | 3 | 2,095 | 698.3 | 0.14% | |
Republika Srpska | 3 | 1,039 | 346.3 | Originator blocked as a sock. | 0.29% |
Delaware | 12 | 2,483 | 206.9 | Originator banned. Selected pages same as in 2007. | 0.48% |
Maryland | 15 | 3,315 | 221.0 | Originator inactive since 2016. | 0.45% |
New Jersey | 20 | 4,159 | 208.0 | 0.48% | |
Rhode Island | 12 | 2,760 | 230.0 | 0.43% | |
Connecticut | 16 | 3,109 | 194.3 | Being reworked by MJL. | 0.51% |
Hawaii | 20 | 8,490 | 424.5 | Originator inactive since 2007. | 0.24% |
Subnational entities never have more than approximately 1% of the pageviews of the head article, and never have as many as 40 daily pageviews. (They never have more than 20, but that may change if the table is expanded.)
add keep/delete/comments below this line