The result was keep. I'm closing this as a keep, and if some of those involved in this discussion still feel it should be merged I would encourage you to begin a merge discussion. (non-admin closure) —JmaJeremy✆✎ 02:58, 31 August 2012 (UTC)Reply[reply]
This page has been proposed for deletion in the past, and it was decided to be kept. However, I believe the situation has substantially changed.
The article originally covered a project to produce a replica Titanic which started in 1998, and terminated in 2006. In 2012, a new project was started, and details of this were incorporated in to the article, changing it to a general overview of the 'replica Titanic' concept. This has now been forked in to a separate article - Titanic II - which also contains relevant details of the previous project. I believe this makes this article redundant.
The second section (2012 project) is a summary of the main article, so does not contribute to the usefulness of this page. The remaining information all pertains to the previous project. I believe this does not warrant a full article for the following reasons:
The article has been through several iterations over two years, and has not yet produced a stable, encyclopaedic article. I believe the most appropriate course of action is deletion. MatthewHaywood (talk) 10:50, 24 August 2012 (UTC)Reply[reply]