The result was delete. Cirt (talk) 17:06, 28 March 2009 (UTC)[reply]
This new article is forked out of a dispute at Talk:Coalition casualties in Afghanistan#Canadian soldier killed at the logistics base and is largely a duplicate of Coalition casualties in Afghanistan. Some discussion preceding the forking can be viewed at Talk:Coalition casualties in Afghanistan#Canadian soldier killed at the logistics base. Mike McGregor (Can) (talk) 02:55, 21 March 2009 (UTC)[reply]
Strong Keep It's not a copy. First of all this list doesn't contain the names of the soldiers killed, second except for the list of names I have removed a lot of the other text from this article, change a lot of it and added some new. Yes there are still some points in the article that are the same as that other one but that is to be expected since both articles cover ALMOST the same thing. But it's not the same thing. That other article has been presented as a list of coalition soldiers killed in the war in Afghanistan, but it is not is it? It only lists soldiers killed within the borders of Afghanistan and not those killed in the surrounding countries who also died supporting the war in Afghanistan. There is at least a hundred soldiers killed in surrounding countries in the war in Iraq and not in Iraq but are listed as the victims of that war. Hundreds of US soldiers were killed during the Vietnam war in Cambodia or Laos and not just exclusivly withing Vietnam itself but are listed as victims of that war. All links in the article War in Afghanistan link to that other article so people think that is the true number of soldiers killed, but it is not is it, it's totaly misrepresenting. There NEEDS to be a FULL list of ALL soldiers killed as the result of the War in Afghanistan. I tried to reason this with an anonymous user at the original article but he wouldn't accept even a bit of a compromise. There needs to be a solid list of all coalition fatalities that have resulted from the war in Afghanistan and not just exclusivly within the borders of that country. BobaFett85 (talk) 03:13, 21 March 2009 (UTC)[reply]