The result was merge to Underground Gamer. The consensus is that the article Underground Gamer needs to be created with a subsection about BitGamer, where this will then be merged. :) ·Salvidrim!· ✉ 14:58, 30 June 2013 (UTC)[reply]
Non-notable as per WP:GNG (possibly also WP:NRVE and WP:WEB).
Out of the provided sources, only one may be anywhere close to reliable - the TorrentFreak article covering the website's termination. The remaining three consist of a link to a third-party mirror of the site's torrents - which I'm not sure is even allowed under Wikipedia's copyright policy - and two Reddit discussions which automatically fail WP:RS and WP:NEWSBLOG by the fact of being forum discussions. The Fifth Horseman (talk) 12:23, 19 May 2013 (UTC)[reply]