Proarticulata phylogeny

Proarticulatans are simple Ediacaran animals that have not had any phylogenetic focus due to them being very simple animals and not having many distinguishing characteristics from each other other than perhaps shape. Here I attempt to compile acharacter matrix for proarticulatans and a phylogenetic analysis:

Characters list: numerical

1. cephalic isomer tow fused isomers (0) or curved into one central isomer (1)# basal zone containing rest of isomers
2. isomers border each other (0) or separated (1)
3. surface tubercles
4. 'intestinal cecae/gonad tubules' directed anteriorwards (0) or parallel along isomers (1)

--- quantitative 2-d procrustes-fitted geometric morphometric character points

1. anteriormost point along middle
2. head/first isomer point along middle
3. head/first isomer point along lateral edge (left)
4. widest lateral point (left)
5. posteriormost point along middle

DInosauria

A geometric morphometrics phylogenetic analysis using 30 2-d landmark points on the cranium of 43 taxa, focused on basal Dinosauria and Theropoda.

Note that Noasauridae is a mess and the software has no idea where to place these bizarre-skulled animals.

Data matrix will be added below.

And yes, I know, it's original research, but this is, after all, a user page, not an article.

With a total of 58 added taxa, it's more of a mess than before, with Abelisauridae maybe being descended from Allosauroids. Hopefully with the addition of more taxa clarity will be resolved and the tree will reflect known relationships, and perhaps even provide reliable novel relationships based on the analysis. If not, then more characters need to be coded for.

Here's the matrix in MorphoJ format, not procrustes-converted:

Lagosuchus: 3,92,19,90,80,85,79,85,142,82,155,83,161,82,153,53,149,38,123,33,78,36,10,71,10,72,23,79,25,76,47,60,46,65,78,84,78,83,90,80,134,60,138,54,128,76,138,77,151,56,148,39,148,40,123,35,81,41,78,37 Herrerasaurus: 18,57,36,53,70,40,75,40,93,36,105,36,107,31,99,25,90,15,71,14,62,19,20,40,20,42,32,38,34,35,52,27,52,28,60,38,65,38,66,32,81,29,87,25,84,36,95,34,96,25,89,16,89,17,72,15,63,27,62,19 Buriolestes: 6,64,24,56,131,55,134,55,189,55,202,60,214,64,190,34,189,15,165,6,107,13,19,43,21,45,30,47,31,48,76,30,78,32,122,50,117,49,132,48,170,44,179,36,187,54,186,52,190,34,196,16,196,18,154,6,116,11,113,8 Eoraptor: 3,78,16,73,105,66,103,65,133,66,158,70,162,69,153,32,151,13,119,7,83,18,11,52,11,54,27,60,27,52,52,39,41,45,83,63,89,60,93,60,124,52,136,42,134,65,142,64,151,33,155,15,148,18,105,9,95,13,80,19 Panphagia: 22,73,32,68,68,58,74,55,104,49,116,49,119,47,106,29,100,13,87,13,59,27,21,54,23,56,32,60,32,58,55,37,51,37,68,54,64,53,72,49,94,39,99,35,103,48,104,46,104,29,101,15,101,16,89,20,69,23,65,22 Macrocollum: 22,176,41,167,126,137,125,137,176,126,203,125,208,125,183,87,177,67,128,76,107,89,39,120,40,124,45,152,52,125,73,110,84,107,105,135,107,136,123,129,160,107,166,99,175,124,176,123,182,86,178,67,177,69,140,73,123,80,127,76 Asilisaurus: 69,380,223,350,474,342,625,332,860,308,937,326,976,328,902,204,837,92,768,81,438,107,141,228,151,241,258,261,258,261,353,156,360,167,516,294,516,294,596,271,763,213,786,182,820,290,845,282,893,202,865,103,849,116,710,78,540,137,485,97 Heterodontosaurus: 51,222,111,175,231,200,257,186,311,181,343,240,370,243,380,109,336,54,250,65,168,109,62,170,65,171,144,144,153,132,144,145,145,145,190,169,195,154,207,154,268,140,292,125,311,178,326,154,362,114,353,60,350,63,250,71,192,93,186,92 Eocursor: 16,81,32,76,65,64,66,62,92,58,101,59,104,58,94,46,91,31,74,32,48,49,18,67,21,68,39,60,40,59,48,49,50,53,59,60,59,59,63,57,79,50,85,45,92,56,93,54,93,43,92,32,92,34,70,34,55,42,48,42 Gnathovorax: 13,137,66,129,385,160,331,159,533,175,570,205,596,185,549,97,496,52,442,23,310,25,53,48,54,50,155,47,156,46,263,43,263,44,261,130,307,118,372,126,445,108,468,97,515,161,499,149,535,108,525,65,498,74,437,22,360,34,352,16 Eodromaeus: 3,77,13,76,73,70,79,69,146,62,161,62,166,62,152,31,146,12,121,11,77,27,10,52,11,55,19,54,19,50,53,34,58,36,77,65,78,65,95,62,131,48,138,33,143,60,150,57,152,32,149,13,143,16,124,16,85,40,81,23 Tawa: 7,83,25,71,116,71,124,70,171,65,192,60,195,56,179,36,172,14,143,6,87,24,20,55,21,56,38,59,39,58,85,27,86,29,104,64,105,49,116,44,154,41,160,30,157,64,163,62,174,35,174,15,173,16,139,11,110,17,102,16 Pampadromaeus: 3,81,15,72,82,65,88,63,107,62,131,64,135,63,120,34,121,18,93,12,58,32,11,55,12,56,18,65,20,58,39,46,41,48,65,63,64,62,74,57,107,42,111,39,109,61,114,60,120,35,120,19,119,20,95,14,65,34,64,25 Daemonosaurus: 47,183,96,202,292,265,321,269,500,315,526,341,545,330,542,242,538,159,499,97,271,98,135,97,110,113,190,119,193,118,213,113,222,128,252,230,262,219,311,232,434,218,474,188,436,283,466,288,538,242,553,185,522,175,459,87,328,89,276,92 Zupaysaurus: 6,266,82,234,545,228,548,227,742,301,758,307,772,308,779,176,747,98,685,46,420,5,110,140,74,179,106,204,126,181,374,33,406,44,511,194,512,193,546,186,627,199,701,155,640,248,715,271,728,220,769,112,738,117,673,48,592,57,550,23 Dracoraptor: 31,138,80,144,223,142,253,140,433,149,453,153,464,151,463,96,427,33,393,28,265,22,117,82,107,91,106,126,118,106,218,38,237,36,248,114,249,114,287,114,323,118,411,68,437,144,441,139,457,100,426,37,425,41,391,29,284,28,265,22 Panguraptor: 438,144,480,146,600,165,636,173,700,183,720,191,726,190,731,136,708,105,658,83,609,86,475,112,470,119,484,130,485,128,580,94,565,101,620,162,621,161,630,161,672,152,682,144,699,181,697,180,731,135,710,109,706,114,664,93,627,81,625,80 Coelophysis: 15,348,47,346,251,350,264,350,317,361,333,365,341,365,336,311,337,287,289,271,236,282,51,320,52,322,62,334,77,326,223,287,219,291,248,339,249,338,269,337,293,329,316,314,315,359,313,356,333,313,335,291,329,297,298,281,266,282,258,277 Megapnosaurus: 5,155,40,151,221,150,272,154,323,164,354,175,360,173,356,109,362,79,314,56,245,74,31,130,32,132,46,143,55,132,228,76,221,81,250,146,250,145,259,145,315,129,331,120,322,163,325,162,353,111,372,87,354,90,323,73,267,72,257,66 "Syntarsus": 393,392,433,381,639,385,651,385,729,396,745,404,753,405,730,333,707,305,672,303,611,303,426,347,418,358,443,369,445,367,576,308,558,320,623,375,624,375,634,373,689,360,702,345,742,392,718,387,728,334,721,311,713,317,683,313,637,312,627,300 Dilophosaurus: 36,106,47,97,108,88,109,87,135,78,144,77,147,75,133,59,124,47,110,47,98,30,48,81,46,86,51,91,59,84,81,63,82,64,91,81,97,79,108,75,115,66,118,61,125,78,132,74,129,60,125,48,124,49,110,52,109,51,111,46 Saltriovenator: 11,99,22,93,87,68,107,61,125,58,145,52,148,50,119,25,106,12,83,18,55,35,12,67,12,70,18,79,22,73,57,36,57,38,75,57,78,54,87,52,98,37,100,26,111,57,115,56,118,29,108,13,108,14,85,20,80,21,79,19 Ceratosaurus: 30,101,43,98,120,76,130,72,152,69,186,56,190,48,156,27,143,14,116,21,87,32,36,61,36,64,42,76,43,75,74,43,90,37,115,68,116,67,126,62,137,51,138,34,147,69,154,65,157,30,145,17,139,22,117,23,112,25,112,23 C."dentisulcatus": 15,107,24,101,93,81,111,72,145,67,169,59,172,53,140,32,123,17,97,22,59,41,15,71,16,72,24,81,24,81,59,43,62,46,94,71,94,71,104,64,117,47,120,29,125,67,138,64,139,34,128,20,121,24,98,25,91,27,91,24 Chilesaurus: 10,36,13,36,30,37,33,35,59,39,59,41,61,42,64,25,58,18,49,16,29,16,16,23,17,24,13,34,18,25,22,23,20,25,33,34,34,34,35,33,49,30,50,30,59,37,59,35,60,25,58,19,58,20,49,16,33,16,30,16 Sinosaurus: 135,675,267,557,899,647,1085,621,1441,685,1647,685,1663,641,1525,455,1445,247,1301,229,873,47,263,373,263,411,361,449,379,435,791,281,801,291,921,555,919,553,1111,547,1231,469,1339,393,1309,633,1479,615,1495,459,1437,269,1429,295,1259,279,1197,249,1229,193 Limusaurus: 32,437,208,387,393,385,567,395,851,415,898,437,921,451,926,282,906,132,803,120,470,195,175,244,180,282,201,379,244,317,387,230,387,230,520,383,521,383,590,380,794,346,834,269,856,412,858,410,912,289,907,134,909,136,789,122,473,195,471,196 Masiakasaurus: 19,74,98,94,316,181,356,196,502,284,531,317,541,312,544,222,559,132,461,74,376,60,109,8,98,17,117,76,126,70,290,43,287,45,319,170,319,169,359,177,458,217,518,164,468,254,486,264,541,221,571,153,543,150,454,76,390,72,375,60 Eoabelisaurus: 4,98,12,97,96,84,100,82,132,84,173,79,176,77,152,44,126,7,95,7,45,33,6,75,7,76,17,83,19,77,46,38,49,40,77,71,85,60,90,65,113,41,115,39,126,77,121,67,148,43,125,10,125,13,96,13,95,13,94,8 Indosuchus: 8,136,48,147,200,151,222,151,330,171,394,167,416,164,383,110,367,42,260,13,184,18,88,42,63,66,87,78,87,77,172,32,176,40,172,110,226,108,245,109,284,96,316,72,313,159,340,152,363,109,357,46,346,54,276,25,276,25,259,12 Rugops: 31,382,90,405,460,455,611,422,768,452,902,431,911,424,892,384,840,121,647,35,618,44,215,114,271,119,271,119,271,119,480,60,494,99,424,351,511,311,572,295,656,311,760,226,692,418,783,410,831,305,838,136,791,158,645,51,605,62,619,43 Spectrovenator: 10,106,22,113,148,114,167,114,232,124,261,110,267,106,229,74,223,27,181,24,120,32,28,70,35,81,42,82,42,82,116,39,133,39,129,93,139,85,151,86,184,81,207,54,236,118,221,108,229,74,216,32,209,42,182,34,182,34,181,24 Majungasaurus: 17,115,27,111,77,90,88,86,108,81,129,79,133,76,115,47,100,35,81,35,69,38,19,83,21,88,26,93,28,89,46,65,47,68,57,84,71,72,76,70,88,86,93,56,96,80,104,77,112,58,106,39,100,42,71,38,71,38,69,38 Rajasaurus: 19,128,46,131,191,135,207,132,262,143,318,141,327,133,303,89,289,41,236,23,152,22,43,68,50,69,75,86,75,86,149,34,185,42,152,100,196,82,208,88,234,81,251,74,243,132,276,130,299,87,282,42,283,45,226,23,226,23,196,19 Skorpiovenator: 11,107,21,107,90,84,96,80,110,71,136,54,137,52,111,29,109,17,63,16,43,34,6,79,7,80,14,81,13,72,44,40,44,41,53,71,65,55,75,58,84,49,91,37,102,68,111,61,112,43,97,19,98,21,63,16,63,16,63,16 Ekrixinatosaurus: 19,226,47,234,283,244,297,240,358,233,426,224,440,214,412,112,406,78,271,24,192,55,32,146,35,147,61,154,61,154,193,69,193,74,193,177,237,143,264,161,297,143,330,114,328,218,361,207,378,152,385,68,367,77,271,24,271,24,271,24 Carnotaurus: 11,342,65,370,308,427,337,431,422,421,532,427,561,407,488,270,442,144,352,105,263,110,58,219,49,236,104,267,104,267,240,151,233,152,229,337,269,297,299,304,363,261,368,256,401,413,443,395,480,271,453,159,435,167,299,109,299,109,263,110 Aucasaurus: 4,82,12,84,72,76,90,72,103,72,126,66,130,64,109,26,95,14,59,22,48,29,4,61,6,62,13,66,13,66,38,43,38,43,68,65,69,55,72,54,90,39,92,38,98,69,102,66,107,28,95,15,96,17,59,22,59,22,59,22 Abelisaurus: 7,309,62,343,417,385,469,375,724,399,863,408,879,371,807,263,765,106,666,63,492,52,135,122,116,172,87,246,143,188,390,100,390,105,459,279,475,243,504,243,584,241,628,209,710,379,719,359,794,265,766,133,746,131,666,63,666,63,666,63 Cryolophosaurus: 20,151,96,171,338,279,346,281,503,347,591,375,609,373,608,247,594,170,546,139,415,89,138,83,132,97,122,127,176,104,412,102,405,111,333,247,403,234,454,247,503,234,557,221,512,340,509,328,575,269,590,179,584,186,523,152,495,142,519,120 Monolophosaurus: 18,103,34,94,97,74,114,67,143,58,157,56,160,53,143,32,125,18,107,21,99,25,33,50,23,71,42,73,49,66,73,43,77,45,96,62,101,58,116,53,121,52,125,37,131,60,142,54,140,39,135,20,127,22,109,24,102,29,99,24 Torvosaurus: 8,97,25,93,95,70,115,66,166,56,182,51,185,44,153,21,129,10,115,15,82,31,26,59,28,60,26,75,26,75,81,33,81,34,103,62,103,62,122,52,130,48,132,40,150,59,163,51,151,24,137,11,139,12,117,18,104,26,103,20 Wiehenvenator: 15,262,101,276,509,279,633,295,844,314,892,320,942,318,864,158,811,38,660,21,523,30,149,72,143,85,149,157,224,129,513,34,519,49,567,219,567,219,638,203,682,215,738,141,743,293,810,275,829,161,808,43,796,48,658,50,626,58,616,23 Eustreptospondylus: 18,147,78,142,312,132,351,134,458,152,519,167,549,168,508,73,457,13,388,10,303,10,97,53,85,65,100,95,137,86,303,13,307,20,303,113,325,98,364,108,400,108,431,82,451,146,452,140,492,75,484,25,458,29,407,24,374,23,374,10 Afrovenator: 31,269,127,264,490,276,564,288,757,282,760,295,809,295,772,167,677,43,598,43,481,48,156,116,131,140,166,182,211,172,458,73,453,93,462,225,478,211,566,221,605,214,651,159,668,273,718,259,743,171,772,89,694,83,604,65,574,74,569,47 Dubreuillosaurus: 4,136,60,135,272,126,307,127,403,149,460,167,489,168,446,75,401,4,347,4,224,10,79,52,63,66,78,93,112,85,219,16,244,22,265,108,284,97,320,103,347,107,380,64,395,143,396,139,429,78,425,15,413,18,347,14,338,16,337,5 Marshosaurus: 12,112,27,104,97,75,108,69,152,56,174,51,180,45,164,21,145,9,109,17,69,38,11,76,12,79,27,81,27,81,64,44,70,43,91,66,98,59,113,57,125,46,129,28,138,58,153,51,158,21,143,11,140,13,110,21,101,25,99,21 Asfaltovenator: 12,302,78,296,389,264,481,266,665,281,698,299,719,285,632,143,585,59,513,25,390,18,58,142,104,128,144,182,144,182,354,49,362,82,360,220,410,188,463,183,511,205,541,157,546,264,612,253,606,167,614,90,571,79,496,61,481,63,479,23 Yangchuanosaurus: 22,216,40,212,199,193,241,180,362,172,374,171,381,163,333,87,340,48,252,30,147,53,42,120,38,133,61,143,61,143,154,61,160,76,198,168,210,153,240,139,267,127,290,86,293,173,305,167,327,91,321,45,300,42,254,43,242,40,240,31 "Y"or"S"hepingensis: 42,985,151,983,918,779,1119,722,1531,674,1796,605,1848,537,1637,174,1331,47,1174,75,753,183,124,627,133,665,204,735,204,735,712,280,806,294,894,663,920,607,1116,587,1227,463,1314,335,1461,642,1545,588,1634,456,1395,59,1440,83,1200,159,1091,227,1074,79 Sinraptor: 67,914,187,919,1003,736,1159,720,1594,662,1778,656,1830,588,1596,246,1333,78,1114,97,800,153,141,557,77,672,238,719,238,719,707,227,750,288,919,650,993,595,1107,539,1242,474,1333,298,1409,680,1463,630,1563,319,1387,113,1353,143,1098,171,1044,208,1041,89 Ajimmadseni: 43,334,84,325,383,306,438,320,613,345,734,349,764,338,714,203,638,68,525,67,348,68,65,189,81,196,122,233,122,233,313,97,328,102,379,264,379,264,464,275,524,224,575,176,574,324,610,322,669,249,702,124,607,122,543,124,476,114,509,64 Afragilis: 15,238,63,237,321,232,370,248,482,295,563,305,597,299,560,188,544,65,465,50,287,42,69,93,79,108,114,139,124,134,280,61,283,77,305,190,305,190,379,190,427,181,457,176,460,283,495,275,529,225,583,136,552,124,440,72,419,71,424,46 Neovenator: 16,246,59,242,296,234,367,227,468,240,551,238,559,228,521,169,492,83,372,52,280,54,104,129,103,145,69,198,75,196,272,72,239,115,281,209,312,198,365,178,407,173,457,114,441,230,472,219,487,150,508,102,466,102,377,84,377,84,372,52 Baryonyx: 61,152,78,145,135,131,152,125,188,121,201,122,206,119,196,107,189,94,175,93,172,95,99,127,93,131,96,136,107,128,158,103,159,104,155,121,155,121,166,110,180,106,183,104,185,119,182,116,195,107,189,95,188,96,176,96,173,96,172,95 Acrocanthosaurus: 8,107,20,102,82,74,110,72,130,69,159,60,162,54,139,27,118,11,99,15,58,32,12,74,13,75,29,71,30,69,59,33,59,39,74,68,86,61,103,58,111,47,117,29,127,68,138,60,139,28,128,14,126,15,100,19,84,20,94,17 Suchomimus: 47,358,64,352,131,338,136,335,189,326,204,327,204,323,194,311,185,304,168,308,162,309,85,330,74,338,86,340,90,339,153,313,153,315,134,332,141,330,154,325,171,320,176,316,187,325,185,324,193,313,186,304,182,306,170,309,163,311,163,309 Irritator: 23,219,69,190,179,137,213,120,268,120,299,122,307,113,291,73,288,43,260,25,223,43,122,116,111,139,111,143,136,130,194,62,198,68,205,103,205,103,230,86,256,72,260,70,243,108,272,106,289,82,289,51,281,50,253,33,235,40,227,33 — Preceding unsigned comment added by Hiroizmeh (talk • contribs) 01:53, 22 April 2021 (UTC)

As of 67 taxa: Hiroizmeh (talk) 04:03, 6 May 2021 (UTC)

}

If clades were defined by amount of time instead of members