Source assessment table:
| ||||
Source | Independent? | Reliable? | Significant coverage? | Count source toward GNG? |
---|---|---|---|---|
USA Today | Reliable source | Appears to be from an established journalist | ~ The article about 40% about her but it's mostly about the company and invention | ~ Partial |
Fortune Magazine | ? Behind a paywall and was not able to get access | ? Behind a paywall and was not able to get access | ? Behind a paywall and was not able to get access | ? Unknown |
Fortune Magazine | ? Behind a paywall and was not able to get access | ? Behind a paywall and was not able to get access | ? Behind a paywall and was not able to get access | ? Unknown |
NPR | Public Media | Opinion Article | Article covers the subject and their device | ✘ No |
CNN | Yes as per WP:RSPSS | ~ There is not an author of this article and it's just a list of 15 questions | ~ It's 15 questions and no indepth reporting | ~ Partial |
Business Insider | It appears that this article is independent | ~ As per WP:BUSINESSINSIDER There is no consensus on the reliability of Insider. Also the article is more of a short form letter or pseudo correction | ~ Article is about the subject but also about how the editor at BI underestimated them | ~ Partial |
USA Today | Reliable source | Appears to be from an established journalist | ~ Article covers some of a fraud allegations and is just a revisiting of the previous USA Today article | ~ Partial |
Fortune Magazine | ? Unable to determine if this source is independent or if they included this topic because they had just published an article on the subject | ~ Interview doesn't appear to be in-depth and is only covering the device without indepth reporting on the subject | ~ The article about 40% about her but it's mostly about the company and invention | ? Unknown |
New York Times | NYT is a reliable source | NYT is a reliable source | The article is about the device, the subject is only mentioned in the first two paragraphs | ✘ No |
J. Craig Venter Institute | ? Just a profile for a non-profit | ? Just a profile for a non-profit | Just a profile for a non-profit | ✘ No |
Philadelphia | Appears to have some independent content | ? Article is three paragraphs talking about them appearing in another magazine | Article is three paragraphs talking about them appearing in another magazine | ✘ No |
New York Times | NYT is a reliable source | NYT is a reliable source | Article goes in-depth about the subject | ✔ Yes |
This table may not be a final or consensus view; it may summarize developing consensus, or reflect assessments of a single editor. Created using ((source assess table)). |