Track listing
LP
Capitol Records Catalog Number T-849
Side A
- "I Can't Give You Anything But Love" (Jimmy McHugh, Dorothy Fields) – 2:41
- Session 4779; Master 16532. Recorded January 28, 1957.
- "Only Forever" (James V. Monaco, Johnny Burke) – 2:08
- Session 4784; Master 16545. Recorded January 30, 1957.
- "Sleepy Time Gal" (Ange Lorenzo, Richard A. Whiting, Joseph R. Alden, Raymond B. Egan) – 2:36
- Session 4779; Master 16539. Recorded January 28, 1957.
- "Maybe" (Allan Flynn, Frank Madden) – 2:12
- Session 4784; Master 16527. Recorded January 30, 1957.
- "I Don't Know Why (I Just Do)" (Fred E. Ahlert, Roy Turk) – 2:54
- Session 4784; Master 16529. Recorded January 30, 1957.
- "Pretty Baby" (Egbert Van Alstyne, Tony Jackson, Gus Cahn) – 2:03
- Session 4779; Master 16534. Recorded January 28, 1957.
Side B
- "You've Got Me Crying Again" (Charles Newman, Isham Jones) – 1:44
- Session 4784; Master 16546. Recorded January 30, 1957.
- "Once in a While" (Michael Edwards, Bud Green) – 2:54
- Session 4784; Master 16528. Recorded January 30, 1957.
- "The Object of My Affection" (Pinky Tomlin, Coy Poe, Jimmie Grier) – 2:37
- Session 4784; Master 16530. Recorded January 30, 1957.
- "For You" (Joe Burke, Al Dubin) – 2:20
- Session 4779; 16540. Recorded January 28, 1957.
- "It's Easy to Remember" (Richard Rodgers, Lorenz Hart) – 3:16
- Session 4779; Master 16533. Recorded January 28, 1957.
- "Nevertheless (I'm in Love with You)" (Bert Kalmar, Harry Ruby) – 2:50
- Session 4779; Master 16531. Recorded January 28, 1957.
Compact Disc
1997 EMI/Capitol combined Pretty Baby with This Time I'm Swingin! (from 1960). Catalog Number 7243 8 54546 2 9.
2005 Collectors' Choice Music reissue added four more tracks to the twelve tracks on the original Capitol LP. Catalog Number WWCCM06062.
- "Me 'n You 'n the Moon" (Sammy Cahn, Jimmy Van Heusen) – 2:13
- Session 4380; Master 15482-7. Recorded May 22, 1956.
- "Beau James" (Herbert Baker) – 2:18
- Session 6023; Master 17073-6. Recorded May 22, 1957.
- "I Know Your Mother Loves You" (S. Cahn, Arthur Schwartz) – 2:41
- Session 3753; Master 13751-5. Recorded April 27, 1955.
- "The Lady with the Big Umbrella" (David Nelson, Danny Goodman) – 2:58
- Session 3746; Master 13724-8. Recorded April 20, 1955.